Palah Biswas On Unique Identity No1.mpg

Unique Identity No2

Please send the LINK to your Addresslist and send me every update, event, development,documents and FEEDBACK . just mail to palashbiswaskl@gmail.com

Website templates

Zia clarifies his timing of declaration of independence

what mujib said

Jyothi Basu Is Dead

Unflinching Left firm on nuke deal

Jyoti Basu's Address on the Lok Sabha Elections 2009

Basu expresses shock over poll debacle

Jyoti Basu: The Pragmatist

Dr.BR Ambedkar

Memories of Another day

Memories of Another day
While my Parents Pulin Babu and basanti Devi were living

"The Day India Burned"--A Documentary On Partition Part-1/9

Partition

Partition of India - refugees displaced by the partition

Saturday, March 6, 2010

The Fire Within Slums and Slum dwellers in the Age of Unique Identity Number and Regime of LPG Mafia!

The Fire Within Slums and Slum dwellers in the Age of Unique Identity Number and Regime of LPG Mafia!


Indian Holocaust My Father`s Life and Time - THREE HUNDRED ONE

Palash Biswas

http://indianholocaustmyfatherslifeandtime.blogspot.com/

  1. Unique identification scheme for all in Mumbai, even those from Bangladesh

    Times of India - ‎7 hours ago‎
    ... would be eligible to get a number under the central government's Unique Identification (UID) Scheme, according to Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation ...

    PC border alert over population register

    Hindustan Times - ‎Mar 4, 2010‎
    ... chiefs on the National Population Register, which could form the principal database for theUnique Identity Number to be issued by the UID authority. ...

    Work for Unique Identification Project to begin with Census

    The Hindu - ‎Feb 21, 2010‎
    PTI Along with Census 2011, work on database for the ambitious Unique Identification Project will also begin to provide national identity number (NIN) to ...

    Population register creation from April 1

    Daily News & Analysis - Anil Anand - ‎Mar 4, 2010‎
    The home ministry initiative aims at bringing homogeneity between NPR and unique identity (UID) numbers to be allotted by the Nandan Nilekani-led UID ...

    PIE Soft to help find lost key chains

    Business Standard - ‎Mar 4, 2010‎
    The key would be delivered to its owner with the help of this unique ID number," he said. PIE Software has tied up with India Post for free delivery of the ...

    India Having Tech Advisory Group for E-governance Projects

    PC World - John Ribeiro - ‎Feb 26, 2010‎
    The move comes as the Indian government is preparing to invest in a large number of e-governance projects, including on a project to give unique identity ...

    Privacy will be protected under UIDs: Nilekani

    Economic Times - ‎Feb 27, 2010‎
    NEW DELHI: Privacy will be protected under the Unique Identity (UID) project and personal data will not be accessible to everybody, insists Nandan Nilekani, ...

    A year of UID: Much more than a number

    Business Standard - Leslie D'Monte - ‎Feb 19, 2010‎
    The Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDAI), set up to issue a unique identification (UID) number to all 1.2 billion Indian residents, ...

    Nandan Nilekani to test the waters for unique IDs

    Economic Times - ‎Feb 28, 2010‎
    UIDAI aims to provide a unique 16-digit number ID card to at least 600 million residents over the next five years starting from August. ...

    Telecom to map India assets: Pitroda

    Financial Express - ‎Mar 4, 2010‎
    ... said the exercise would be as big in scope as the Unique Identification Database, which aims to provide aunique identity number to each individual. ...


    1. Striving to abolish child labour in India - Guardian Weekly

      When we arrive at the slum in Old Delhi we split into small teams and ... and have a nice long holiday on the day that child labour is abolished in India...
      www.guardianweekly.co.uk/?page=editorial&id=1389&catID... - Cached - 
    2. Indianexpress.com : comments : Pvt sector role needed to make ...

      Pvt sector role needed to make India slum-free: Govt .... Criminals and dynasty rule should be abolished from politics.10. ...
      www.indianexpress.com/...india-slumfree.../515978/ - United States - Cached - 
    3. MC accused of including posh localities slums list - Chandigarh ...

      MC accused of including posh localities slums list ... another councillor, suggested that octroi should not be abolished. he asked the government to clarify how it proposed to ... Latest News from ... This Section; The Times of India ...
      timesofindia.indiatimes.com › City › Chandigarh - Cached - 
    4. [GKD] Cyber-Revolution in India's Slums

      20 Apr 2001 ... The Government abolished the system of lifting human waste many years ....Cyber-Revolution in India's Slums Dear GKD Members, Computers, ...
      ces.iisc.ernet.in/hpg/envis/.../infocyb210501.htmlCached - Similar - 
    5. School In India Question & Answers - Ask & Answer Questions on ...

      will reduce the slums in INDIA....Educate the kinds in the slums and ... Bribe is not a official thing, which can be abolished by administrative order. ...
      sawaal.ibibo.com/search/school-in-india/recent - Cached - 
    6. T J S George: Our Poverty + Their Wealth = India

      ... of the pitiable levels of human degradation we see in the slums of India. Countries like Malaysia needed only two decades to virtually abolish poverty. ...
      www.ourkarnataka.com/Articles/starofmysore/povindia09.htm - Cached - 
    7. Fedina - Informations

      Emphasis: "Empowerment of senior citizens living in slums – to live in dignity". ... procedures for senior citizens in slumsabolishing all discriminatory clauses. ... The Community Based Sanitation and Slum Development (CBS-SD), India ...
      www.borda.de/homepages/india/fedina/modules/.../index.php?id=6 - Cached - 
    8. Major fire in Kolkata slum, News - Nation - Mumbai Mirror

      6 Mar 2010 ... Kolkata: A major fire broke out in a slum area on the eastern ... C...more BangaloreMirror.com - Abolish income tax : Subhash Banka says I totally agree with Mr. Murthy. ..... Times of India | Economic Times | BizXchange ...
      www.mumbaimirror.com/.../Major-fire-in-Kolkata-slum.html - 10 hours ago - 
    9. Our Poverty + their Wealth=India - Mainstream Weekly

      6 Jun 2009 ... Sometimes it takes a foreign eye to see India in perspective. ... of the pitiable levels of human degradation we see in the slums of India. Countries like Malaysia needed only two decades to virtually abolish poverty. ...
      www.mainstreamweekly.net/article1422.htmlCached - Similar - 
    10. From A World to Win News Service - Book review: Planet of Slums

      15 Sep 2008 ... a condition faced by 700 million people in India; and not having access ... A shocking fact from Planet of Slums is that "an estimated 60 percent ... had been re-housed and most urban shantytowns had been abolished...
      revcom.us/a/143online/AWTW_Planet-en.htmlCached - 

      1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Next


      Slum Dwellers in Indian Cities: The Case of Surat in Western India

      by B Das - Cited by 2 - Related articles
      Downloadable! Among the many problems associated with urban growth in India, an increase in the proportion of slums and squatters especially in its 'metros' ...
      ideas.repec.org/p/qeh/qehwps/qehwps07.htmlCached - Similar - 
    1. Homeless International - India: SPARC

      According to UN-HABITAT, India is home to 63% of all slum dwellers in South Asia. This amounts to 170 million people, 17% of the world's slum dwellers...
      www.homeless-international.org/standard_1.aspx?id... - Cached - Similar - 
    2. Slum dwellers in India and risk of HIV.

      Slum dwellers in India and risk of HIV. ... LESSONS LEARNT: The knowledge of the slumpeople was very poor and full of doubts. Women had worse knowledge as ...
      gateway.nlm.nih.gov/MeetingAbstracts/102254116.htmlCached - Similar - 
    3. who are the slum-dwellers in India - Sulekha coffeehouse Forums

      QueSeraSera posted Re:who are the slum-dwellers in India on 12 mnths ago. Yes, slums in ALL Indian cities have people of ALL castes living in small houses. ...
      forums.sulekha.com/.../who-are-the-slum-dwellers-in-India-924212.htm -Cached - Similar - 
    4. Slumdwellers of India cities - The sad story of good people ...

      3 posts - 3 authors - Last post: 15 May 2004
      Slumdwellers of India cities - The sad story of good people Government of India expose Politicians.
      hindustan.net › ... › Government of India expose Politicians - Cached - Similar - 
    5. 62 million slumdwellers, but India will be slum free: Selja

      12 Sep 2009 ... New Delhi, Sep 12 (IANS) India has a whopping 62 million slumdwellers but it aims to be free of shanties through a slew of schemes such as earmarking of 20 ...
      www.thaindian.com/.../62-million-slumdwellers-but-india-will-be-slum-free-selja_100246490.html - United States - Cached - Similar - 
    6. 62 million slumdwellers, but India will be slum free: Selja ...

      According to a 2001 survey, there are 62 million slumdwellers in India, housing and urban poverty alleviation minister Kumari Selja said.
      timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/...slumdwellers...India...slum.../5003226.cms -Cached - 
    7. Slum - SHACK / SLUM DWELLERS INTERNATIONAL [SDI]

      About 200000 live in Slums. SUPF was formed in 1993 with support from the National Slum Dwellers Federation of India and has been part of SDI since 1996. ...
      www.sdinet.org/documents/doc16.htmCached - Similar - 
    8. India - Slum dwellers organise against demolitions

      The recent spate of demolitions has brought slum dwellers together and an umbrella organization "Jan Aandolan" (People's Movement) has been formed. ...
      www.internationalviewpoint.org › ... › IV374 - January 2006 - Cached - Similar - 
    9. SPARC

      The Society for the Promotion of Area Resource Centres (SPARC) is an Indian NGO that supports two people's movements - the National Slum Dwellers Federation ...
      www.sparcindia.org/ - Cached - Similar - 

      1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Next

      Image results for Kolkata slums

       - Report images
      1. Slumdwellers in kolakata

      2. Body Mass Index and Chronic Energy Deficiency Among Urban Bengalee ...

        by R Chakraborty - 2006 - Related articles
        Bengalee urban male slum dwellers of Kolkata, India. Materials and Methods. This study was carried out as part of an ongoing research project being ...
        www.springerlink.com/index/l1251307361784jv.pdf
      3. The Telegraph - Calcutta (Kolkata) | Jharkhand | <B>House that ...

        28 May 2009 ... Ranchi, May 27: Slum dwellers residing in the state capital need not brace against the monsoon this year. Rather, they can look forward to ...
        www.telegraphindia.com/1090528/jsp/.../story_11027481.jspCached - 
      4. Reaching the slum-dwellers through Community Health Volunteers ...

        by P Nag - 2002
        Reaching the slum-dwellers through Community Health Volunteers (CHV)- an experiences of World Vision India (WVI) in Kolkata. Nag P, Misra K, Alyocis W; ...
        gateway.nlm.nih.gov/MeetingAbstracts/102253114.htmlCached - 
      5. Chidambaram distributes loan cheques to slum dwellers, News ...

        7 Jan 2010 ... To help slum dwellers start their business and gain educational benefits, home minister P Chidambaram distributed loan cheques to the needy ...
        www.kolkatamirror.com/index.aspx?page=article&sectid=12... - Cached - 
      6. [PDF] 

        Slum Dwellers and Community Development

        File Format: PDF/Adobe Acrobat - Quick View
        by S Bhattacharya - 2006 - Related articles
        Slum Dwellers and Community Development. Swaha Bhattacharya. University of Calcutta,Kolkata components. When one has a sense of ...
        medind.nic.in/jak/t06/i1/jakt06i1p213.pdfSimilar - 
      7. KMC to remodel slums, forgets to tell slum dwellers - Express India

        But the authorities forgot to tell the good news to the slum dwellers. According to theKolkata Municipal Corporation, Rs 250 crore will be spent on ...
        www.expressindia.com/latest...to...slum-dwellers/245567/ - Yemen - Cached - 
      8. Construction Of Housing For Urban Poor And Rehabilitation Of Slum ...

        Senior general manager of rajarhat new town, kolkata, 700 156 invites tender for construction of housing for urban poor and rehabilitation of slum dwellers ...
        tenders.indiamart.com/details/831418552/Cached - 
      9. Kolkata man sets up medical bank for slum-dwellers

        Kolkata man sets up medical bank for slum-dwellers. CNN-IBN. Time Published on Wed, Mar 12, 2008 at 15:49 in India section. Tags: India's Real Heroes, ...
        ibnlive.in.com › India - Cached - Similar - 
      10. Livelihood details of Kolkata slumdwellers:An official study | MYSME

        Among Kolkata slumdwellers,factory workers are among the highest earners. Although their wages are not high, their income is regular and secure. ...
        www.mysmenews.com/hi/node/403Cached - 
      11. Slum dwellers fight off goons - Kolkata - City - The Times of India

        Trouble broke out when goons allegedly tried to evict slum dwellers at gunpoint near Bengal Jute Mill at Howrah's Bichalighat, off Foreshore Road, ...
        maillogout.indiatimes.com/.../kolkata-/Slum-dwellers.../4298274.cms - Cached - 

      Did you mean to search for: Slum Dwellers in kolkata  


        1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Next


        Local business results for Tannery near Kolkata, West Bengal

        Great Eastern Tannery

        maps.google.co.in - 033 21147775 - More

        Crescent Tannery

        maps.google.co.in - 033 23438869 - More

        Lunar Tannery

        maps.google.co.in - 033 23630487 - More

        Ahmed Tannery

        maps.google.co.in - 033 23430698 - More

        Mow Chong Tannery Pvt Ltd

        www.mowchong.com - 033 23284071 - More

        Moi Tong Tannery

        maps.google.co.in - 033 23292552 - More

        Fu Chang Tannery

        maps.google.co.in - 033 23283088 - More
          More results near Kolkata, West Bengal »


        big fire accident took kolkata place. The accident took place in a slum area of northeast Kolkata. All shelters & huts there have been fired. 
        <object width="480" height="385"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/9j0XxLJgJPU&hl=en_US&fs=1&"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/9j0XxLJgJPU&hl=en_US&fs=1&" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="480" height="385"></embed></object>

        1. Liberia: Slums on Fire | Liberian Observer

          Among the communities where previous fire incidents that have occurred, ... the most risk offire incident recurrence. Take a look at the Slums on Fire...
          www.liberianobserver.com/node/4428Cached - 
        2. Activists demand judicial inquiry into fire accidents in city ...

          Addressing mediapersons here, Prof A Marx of the People's Union for Human Rights alleged that many slums in the city were catching fire for inexplicable ...
          timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/...fire...in...slums/.../4869478.cms - Cached - 
        3. acjnewsline2009

          There is no separate register for the fire accidents in slums or any ... A George, a fire officer in the city says that there are incidents when rats take ...
          acjnewsline.asianmedia.org.in/Thufail_slum%20fire.html - Cached - 
        4. Fire in Mumbai slums affects about 250 dwellings - Worldnews.com

          28 Feb 2010 ... The incident left behind a lot of people as homeless. The fire was ... Surat, Feb 11 (ANI): A major fire broke out in a slum in Surat on. ...
          article.wn.com/.../Fire_in_Mumbai_slums_affects_about_250_dwellings/ - Cached - 
        5. Tamil Nadu Fire & Rescue Services - Interaction with Others

          With more and more huts getting replaced with fire proof dwellings, it is hoped that fireaccidents in slums and hutment areas can be reduced substantially, ...
          www.tnfrs.tn.nic.in/other-org.htmCached - Similar - 
        6. Visualisation of fire incidents using, Map Animation, in Arcview ...

          Past Fire Incidents Layer generated from data provided by the Central Fire ... These were the areas that were highly congested, mostly slums and areas of ...
          www.gisdevelopment.net/application/natural.../fire/mi0399pf.htm - Cached - 
        7. Visualisation of fire incidents using, Map Animation, in Arcview ...

          The fire incidents layer (point map), the roads layer and the river layer was ... These were the areas that were highly congested, mostly slums and areas of ...
          www.gisdevelopment.net › Geospatial Application Papers - Cached - Similar - 
        8. The Daily Star Web Edition Vol. 5 Num 997

          Fire incidents haunt Ctg slum dwellers. Dwaipayan Barua Around 30, 000 people are living in 600 slums in densely populated South Bakalia area in the port ...
          www.thedailystar.net/2007/03/21/d703213502158.htmCached - 
        9. Minor burnt to death in Delhi slum fire

          1 post - 1 author - Last post: 8 May 2009
          The incident took place when fire broke out in one of the slums and spread to the nearbyslums near Batla House of Jamia Nagar in south ...
          www.thaindian.com/.../minor-burnt-to-death-in-delhi-slum-fire_100190006.html - United States - Cached - 
        10. THOUGHTS ON ARCHITECTURE AND URBANISM: Slums Clearances by Fire

          22 Nov 2009 ... Fire in slums politically motivated?. Published August 8th 2009). ... (From Slumdog Millionaire kids escape slum fire...
          myriammahiques.blogspot.com/2009/.../slums-clearances-by-fire.html - Cached - 

          1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Next


          A fire razed over 500 hutments of Panchannagram slums in Tiljala at the Eastern Metropolitan Bypass, leaving thousands homeless. No casualties, however, were reported.The Victims are mostly SC, ST, OBC and Minority Origin Mulnivasi Underprivileged settled around DIDI Matua Mamata Banerjees Political Party TMC Headquarter. The Tannery of TANGRA, in Parc Circus Beleghat area has also been shifted in this area. Tiljala had been one of the largest slums of Kolkata that has since developed into an area populated with lower-income inhabitants. Originally housing refugees coming from Bangladesh and exhibiting very precarious conditions of urban life, it has continuously been upgraded and has now reached a level of a lower middle class neighborhood.


          According to the fire department and police, the fire broke out at around 6.30 pm on Sunday.


          According to fire department sources, at least 20 fire engines were pressed into service to douse the flames at the slum on the Eastern Metropolitan Bypass near Science City auditorium. 

          "The slum was full of combustible items and leather products, which aggravated the fire at a massive pace. The fire broke out at around 11.30 am," a fire department source said. 

          "We cannot ascertain the exact reason of the fire now," he said.

          Mind you, after the Basnati Colony, Ultadanga Fire, it is the Sixth Fire Incident in the Metro area!

          What is the history of Tiljala? 

          Informal settlements are usually represented as areas of pure misery without any distinction or character. They are not thought of as containing different neighborhoods, nor having preferred or privileged areas. It's residents are reduced to purely suffering beings, lacking any individuality, identity or culture. A vast and homogeneous area of deprivation without any heterogeneity or diversity. Even if maybe intended in a caring (i.e. attention-raising) way, this disregard of difference robs the inhabitants of their individuality and therefore of one of their last assertions of a humane life.

          I have interactions with the Residents time to time and know that not only Bengalies, a great Number of Hindi speaking as well as Punjabies live in the area and they have been forcibly Uprooted from their Livelihood and Home in the area which has become the den of Political Muscle Power and Irregular Economic Activities and Underground Business and Crime!

          The fire spread rapidly in the slum, the locals said. At least 15 fire engines were brought in to control the blaze.

          Slum dwellers and the authorities said the explosion of LPG cylinders in some huts caused the blaze.

          The narrow slum lanes and the lack of ready water supply added more problems for fire department teams.

          The large fire engines could not reach the blaze as they had to refill their tanks from a water source few kilometres away.

          The police had sealed off a section of the bypass to let the the fire engines move freely and avoid any major traffic jams from Park Circus side. Residents said they ran out of their homes after they heard several loud explosions.

          "We later figured out that it may have been gas cylinders. Most of the material used to build this hut is highly combustible, and the fire spread very quickly. We lost all our personal possessions," said Rani Mondal.

          Fire Department personnel said the single-storey nature of the constructions made it easier for them to douse the flames, though the lack of water was slowing things down.

          Police said electricity supply to the area had been cut off to avoid further mishaps. 

          the much hyped rs 320 crore calcutta leather complex at bantala finds few takers. the state government took the initiative to shift all tanneries in kolkata, mostly concentrated in tangra, tiljala and topsia area in the eastern fringes of the city following a supreme court ruling, directing the government to make arrangements for shifting the tanneries outside the city to check pollution. 

          state government officials feel that already the project which has been running well behind schedule, might get further delayed for want of participation of the tannery units. 

          though basic infrastructures like roads, drainage and water supply are nearing completion, the treatment plant is yet come up. another problem is the encroachment. though the cmda, the supervising authority, has built more than 250 houses beside the complex for rehabilitation of the locals who will have to be evicted for the project, officials of m.l. dalmiya & co. , the build operate and transfer partner of the state government, feel that the number of houses are inadequate which could make the construction of the project delayed. 

          according to an estimate only 133 tannery owners so far have agreed to shift their units to bantala while there are provisions for setting up of around 1,500 leather units there over a vast 1,100 acres. the complex is designed to offer modern amenities for manufacturing leather products. there are an estimated 550 tanneries in the city. 

          in a vist to the complex at bantala, this correspondent found signboards of a few leather units lying scattered in the vast land inside the complex ground. a large number of cattle have found the land a perfect roaming place. the vast land seemed to have no difference with barren agriculture land except well decorated gate and an office at the entry point of the complex. 

          the cmda authorities, however, are hopeful that the project will see the light of the day within a couple of years. " on our part we have made all necessary arrangements. we have already constructed the roads, drainage and water supply arrangements. the rehabilitation scheme is also ready for the locals. i hope the project will not be delayed for an indefinite period," sudhangshu seal, the cmda board member, who made a on the spot survey said.


          Where do the residents of Tiljala come from, what demographic and social groups are they from and what cultures exist in Tiljala? Are people of similar origin settling in the same areas of Tiljala, or does a mixture of cultural or ethnic heritage occur, as is maybe one central characteristic of urbanity? Are there preferred areas and locations in Tiljala, that people try to move to? Is there an middle-class section? Rich families? Do residents move from one area of Tiljala to another? Do they have second residencies in other parts of the city or the country? Are there schools which are preferred, shops which attract many costumers because of the quality of goods, transportation systems which facilitate movement? What is the structure of land ownership in the settlement? What is the history of Tiljala? Which parts are the oldest, which parts are growing fastest? What are the proposals and masterplans that have been developed for the settlement? Could Tiljala be a model of how slums can transform into (lower) middle-class neighborhoods? What has happened to the original population? Have the people remained with the neighborhood being upgraded, or has the neighborhood become the living quarter of a different part of the society, with the original inhabitants being pushed out even further into newer slums?

          These questions have to be answered to understand the Slum dwellers in kolkata! They Never know as our Partition Victim Bengali SC Communities live and die with MIND SET Fixed , modified with Brahaminical Zionist Mind Control blaming the MUSLIMs, Jinnah and Muslim league for their Miserable Plight and Underclass status and NEVER know about the Brahaminical Zionist Conspiracy Global in Free Market Democracy, the latest development followed by Neo Liberal LPG Monopolistic Aggression, Economic Ethnic Cleansing , Segregation, SEZ Retail Chain Infrastructure Drive. Living in the UNAUTHORISED Colonies and Slums, the Majority Mulnivasi Population in and around Kolkata Never know their Legal Status and the Mystery of the Man Made calamities which occur so often. They have no Identity and No Nationality. No Human Right. No Civil Right. They are engaged to pass the time on Ad Hoc Basis with survival strategy top earn daily Bread. They have no idea about the Political System, Economic Reforms, Market Dominating Communities, Citizenship Amendment Act or Unique Identity Number and even their Problems. not to mention the Basic causes of the Problems and the solution! Just because they know the Indian Holocaust as the Result of Religious Partition and have been uprooted from their Folk and Mulnivasi History as well as Identity. These face less people live and die ALONE as an Individual as their Community life based on Econimy and Culture, Livelihood and languages have been killed. 

          The ACADEMIA led by Brahamins with coopted SC, ST, OBC and Minority representaion have reduced their Folk into Folklore and Converted themselves into SUBHUMAN Industrial Urban and Semi Urban By Product.

          It is True in Kolkata as well as True in New Delhi, Mumbai, Chennai, Nagpur, Banglore, Ahmedabad, Lucknow, Hyderabad as elsewhere anywhere in the Country as ST and SC OBC Refugee Population is Completely SEGREGATED and other indigenous aboriginal communities have little Symathy or Communication with them in an Environment of Civil War declared by the Corporate Politics and Government of India supported by Media, Civil Society and Intelligensia completely Brahaminical.

          In Bengal, due the anti Muslim Mindset and departure from Traditional Dalit Muslim Unity, SC Communities have no friends as the OBC Communities do not Identify themselves with the Mulnivasi Majority as they have no Benefit in terms of Resrvation and quota in Bengal as yet. The Brahmin Front Ruling has Isolated SC and refugee Communities and the Slumdwellers from Forty Two Percent OBC and Intense Muslim hatred has desroyed the Abotriginal Indigenous Equations as SC, ST, OBC and Minorities refrain from their only Surviavl Strategy of Mulnivasi concept uniting all the NON Brahaminical Communities as Rock Solid.Even the so called dalit Intellegensia, BSP and Bamcef Activists live with Isolated Segregated Mindset sponsered by the Brahamins and Brahaminical Acdemia.The ICE is very hard to crack! Hence, the Politics and all social, Cultural, economic Activities are vertically divided and Polarised in between Power and Resistance Hegemonies, both of which are Brahaminical and the Brahmins speak SUB Altern!


          Two days after the fire at 40, Strand Road, left a century-old warehouse gutted, West Bengal Fire Services director Gopal Bhattacharya on Tuesday lashed out against the trading community blaming its carelessness for the increase in number of fire accidents.


          With nine fire incidents reported in the city in the last three months, Bhattacharya said the traders are yet to learn from the Nandaram fire, which destroyed the Nandaram market in the Burabazar area last year.


          "Kolkata traders have not learnt anything from the fire which destroyed the entire building. Even today they rampantly flout fire safety norms," said Bhattacharya.


          The inquiry report submitted after the 100-hour-long blaze at Nandaram market had pointed out that the building had violated all fire safety precautions.


          Bhattacharya today further added that none of the warehouses on Strand Road had installed any fire safety measures. "Most of the fires in these areas occur due to electrical short-circuits, but the Kolkata traders do not seem bothered. Why should they blame us for not controlling the fire when these accidents break out because of their negligence," said Bhattacharya.


          Tangra Leather Tannery up in Flames

          tangra-tannery-on-fire

          Two persons were injured in a fire that broke out at a tannery on South Tangra Road near Tiljala this morning.

          Twenty one fire engines fought the blaze for nearly three hours before the fire could be brought under control.

          According to an official of the State Fire and Emergency Services department, the fire broke out at Shiv Tannery around 9 a.m.. As chemicals and other inflammable articles were stored in the leather tannery in kolkata, the fire spread rapidly to the adjoining areas.

          Neither the cause of the fire nor the extent of damage caused by it could be ascertained. A senior State Fire and Emergency Service Department official said that the tanneries didn't have adequate fire safety mechanism.

          Two fire fighters including one Mr Badal Sarkar were injured while fighting the blaze. They were later taken to a local hospital for treatment. An FIR was lodged against the owner of the tannery, police said. "The complaint was lodged against him for not installing fire preventive measures in the tannery," a senior police officer said. The accused is absconding, he added.

          Newsmen, who went to cover the incident, were prevented from doing so by a section of locals. Locals even resisted fire fighters from starting the fire fighting operations alleging delayed arrival of fire tenders. They alleged that fire tenders were not brought to the spot on time though they had called police immediately after the flames were noticed. A senior State Fire and Emergency Services Department official said that they faced immense problems while taking fire tenders nearer to the tannery as the approach roads were narrow.

          Later, a portion of the wall of the factory had to be demolished to make room for the fire tenders. Locals alleged that no action has been taken either by police or the State Fire and Emergency Services department though there were no fire extinguishing arrangement in tanneries located in the area.

          Mr Pratim Chatterjee, state fire minister said action would be taken against the factory owner.

          Source: The Statesman



          News Articles: Slum Fires in Chennai

          The People's Union for Human Rights, an activism group, has 


          recently come out against the government with charges that the recent spate of Chennai slum fires may have been an intential doing.  In the last few months, over 400 houses have been destroyed and five lives have been claimed.

          The Express reports:

          CHENNAI: A fact-finding team that was formed to investigate accidental slum fires in Chennai this year says these slum fires, which claimed five lives and destroyed over 400 huts, could be politically motivated.

          "…What is surprising is that in all these slums where the fire accidents happened, the slum dwellers ere being forced by the government to vacate the place. This eviction proposal was for various developmental projects, including the MRTS project, Vyasarpadi flyover, widening of Vyasarpadi-Basin Bridge Road, Malar Hospital-Nandambakkam Road, War Memorial-Maduravoyal road," said Madhumitha Dutta, activist, who was part of the 12-member team. While the causes for the fires are still under debate, the rehabilitation activities by the government are nothing short of deplorable, she added.


          Kolkata slums destroyed in devastating fire

          A fire destroyed slums adjacent to the Bidhan-nagar railway station in Kolkata and rendered nearly 1000 families homeless in less than three hours. Fire engines could not reach the spot in time due to a blockade of approach roads since morning by agitators. The blockade in the Beliaghata area was by auto rickshaw drivers because of an inadequate supply of LPG gases for their vehicles. The blockade affected traffic to and from the airport and other important areas. The intention of the agitators was to highlight their plight to the authorities because they had to spend as much as three hours in queue to get their refill of gas. The result was late arrival of fire engines and the hurling of blames. Who is to really to blame? Should not the organizers of the mindless agitations be held responsible? These forms of protest have become the standard in Kolkata. No one spares a thought for the sufferings of the common man. Deaths of serious patients during bandhs have happened. Would things change with a change of leadership at the Chief Minister's level? Can Mamata Banerjee assure her electorate that if she becomes the Chief Minister such incidents would cease?







          2006 Kolkata leather factory fire

          From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia




          Promoted Inferno:Fire guts Kolkata markets, spreads to multi-storeys

          Palash Biswas

          Contact: Palash C Biswas, C/O Mrs Arati Roy, Gosto Kanan, Sodepur, Kolkata- 700110, India. Phone: 91-033-25659551
          Email: palashbiswaskl@gmail.com
          Please read,react,circulate and Write.Just Visit:
          http://www.nandigramunited-banga.blogspot.com/

          The blaze was still raging midday Saturday, and officials say they don't yet know how many people have been affected!Around 2,500 shops and several buildings housing tarpaulin and cloth shops were gutted, fire brigade sources said.Shortage of water supply from the nearby Mullickghat pumping station to the area due to power cut compounded the problem for firefighters, the sources said. The inadequacy of the fire fighting system in this eastern metropolis was laid bare, as the army, air force and the airport authorities had to be called in to control the blaze. It was not clear how the early morning fire began but electrical short circuit was reported to be a possible cause. The flames spread across the area engulfing buildings, burning markets. A thick umbrella of noxious fumes covered the sky.

          West Bengal Governor Gopal Krishna Gandhi also reached the spot while Kolkata Municipal Corporation (KMC) mayor Bikash Ranjan Bhattacharaya supervised the fire fighting for a while.

          'People trading or living here never think of danger. There is no arrangement of water while the fire brigade does not have ladders tall enough,' said Bhattacharya.

          As the authorities struggled to contain a devastating fire at the Burrabazar wholesale market that gutted over 2500 shops, Trinamool Congress chief Mamata Banerjee on Sunday accused the West Bengal government of failing to have a proper disaster management mechanism. Claiming that sabotage could not be ruled out, she wondered whether the fire was to evict people. "It has been seen that such fires occur only on Saturdays and Sundays.

          "Political leaders are coming here to be photographed, while none is bothered about the fact that the fire brigade arrived three hours late," she said.

          The blaze left thousands of people homeless! Police and fire officials say a huge fire raged through a market in the east Indian city of Calcutta early Saturday, causing no casualties but destroying more than 1,000 shops and homes.While all shops in the area have been vacated, a large crowd of traders and spectators gathered on the streets. Traders in the area watched helplessly for hours as firemen struggled to bring the fire under control.

          Angry residents and traders said the fire brigade men came late! The fire broke out at around 1.30 a.m. at Tripalpatti, a wholesale market for plastic tarpaulin, on Jamunalal Bajaj Street, possibly from a short circuit. West Bengal Fire Minister Pratim Chatterjee said the traders who had stored flammable articles illegally in the congested area were responsible for the inferno.

          "In an old city like Kolkata, we perhaps cannot prevent this but unlike in many such fire incidents in Mumbai, here we have been able to save human lives," he said.


          While the buildings burned, the traders and residents wailed as they lost everything to the fire.!

          It is quite a ritual in the growing Metroes, megacities, suburbs and cities of importance in Shining Sensex India with Nano Technology of Hightech NRI Ruling Hegemony supported by Money Mafia and Media. Urbanisation and Industrialisation continue as continues the process of Eviction and depopulation!Burrabazar is the wholesale market area of Kolkata with clusters of unplanned and unauthorized constructions. The fire spread fast, fanned by a breeze and helped along by inflammables like plastics, polythene and garments.

          Fires are common in India where safety regulations are often flouted. In Kolkata, Most of the Fire Incidents ocuur on Weekend! Why? Otherwise it is quite Occasional in festival seasons.Burrabazar has become a notorious place of Eviction and Promoterraj via Fire Incidents. The State Machinery helps this mechanism of infrastructural displacement and capture Economy with inherent Inactivity. The Great Ganges follows some hundred Meters away but these Fire Ocurrances are never controlled until and unless targeted depopulation takes place. Big Bosses have the Insurance coverace and thousands avenues to be compensated. But the small traders and tenants have no scope to reaccomodate in the economy, business, livelihood and life! Tata`s joy Ride in Nano, the Lakh takia car has been superimposed in the psyche of the masses with Media Boom! Buddha gestapo has every reason to justify the ways of Marxist capitalist Ways of development! In Fact, Metro Kolkata is geared up to witness a Historical Brigade rally only tomorrow to Celebrate Nandigram Singur Victory. The Genocide master of Marichjhanpi fame, Jyoti Basu is recommended to get Bharat Ratna. Here you are, it was an auspicious occassion for a Promoted Inferno right into the Heart Of Kolkata!

          'The whole situation is sad. There is no disaster management system in place here. If anything happens in the middle of night in Kolkata there is hardly any infrastructure to mitigate it,' said Trinamul Congress leader Mamata Banerjee, who rushed to the spot.

          'Again mysteriously the fire occurred on a Saturday night. I am clueless why all such fires in market areas occur on weekend nights. Is there a plan behind it to evict people?' asked Banerjee, not ruling out sabotage behind the incident.


          A fire that broke out in a market in Kolkata's crammed Burrabazar area in the wee hours on Saturday spread across the area engulfing eight homes, including multi-storeyed buildings, leaving thousands homeless in the heart of the metropolis. Burrabazar, the famous Kolkata wholesale market area with congested clusters of unplanned and unauthorised constructions in the north-central zone, turned into an inferno of flammable plastics, polythene and garments, but no casualty was reported, police said.


          "At least eight buildings are engulfed in fire and six have been affected very badly. A 15-storied house also caught fire," a fire brigade official said.

          "At least 42 fire engines are fighting to put out the blaze. The fire is yet to be brought under control. We are trying our best but there was initially a problem of availability of water," Kolkata Police Commissioner Gautam Mohan Chakraborty said.

          "We have no report of any casualty. No one was trapped inside. We ensured that. We had to ferry the water initially but now that problem was solved," Chakraborty said.


          Local MP Sudhangshu Sil said efforts were on to bring fire-fighting equipment from the Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose International (NSCBI) airport to fight the blaze, which covered the area in a thick umbrella of noxious smoke.


          Defence sources said that two fire tenders each from the Army and the Air Force were also sent to the spot following a request from the state government.

          Stating that ladders of 52 metre height were being used to fight the blaze, the Fire Services Minister said, that although these were the second highest air ladders in the world, those're only meant for rescue purposes.

          The congestion of the roads and lack of proper building plans of the fire-engulfed buildings were adding to the problem, Chatterjee claimed.

          Police said all buildings in the area were evacuated as a precautionary measure and the Mahatma Gandhi Road, connecting Howrah station with the Sealdah Terminus, has been closed to traffic.

          The West Bengal BJP demanded a CBI probe into the Burrabazar fire and immediate dismissal of the Fire Services Minister Pratim Chatterjee.

          "It was an unprecedented fire in recent memory and necessitated requisitioning firemen from the army and airforce. We feel that there must be a conspiracy and specific motive behind the fire at Burrabazar and the CBI should be asked to probe it," Bjp state general secretary Rahulk Sinha said.

          Demanding Chatterjee's dismissal for 'negligence', the BJP leader alleged that the state government was unaware of the mushrooming of multistoreyed buildings without fire safety measures in congested places like Burrabazar.

          "The state government has not yet taken any step in the past on the basis of probes into fires in the city," Sinha alleged.

           

          CPI(M) not to seek Bharat Ratna for Jyoti Basu 
          New Delhi (PTI): The CPI(M) on Saturday put cold water on suggestions for Bharat Ratna to veteran Marxist Jyoti Basu, saying the party does not accept state awards.

          "It is not a practice of our leaders to accept state awards," CPI(M) sources said here when asked for comments on reports suggesting Basu's name for the top civilian award.

          The sources said that during the tenure of P V Narasimha Rao as the Prime Minister, the government had offered Padma Vibhushan to former CPI(M) General Secretary and veteran freedom fighter EMS Namboodiripad.

          The party had turned down the offer even at that time, they said, adding that it has never been the practice to formally ask for such awards.

          The name of the Marxist leader cropped up after senior BJP leader L K Advani wrote a letter to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh recommending that former Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee be given Bharat Ratna.

          "When the name of Atal Bihari Vajpayee came up for Bharat Ratna, there is nothing wrong in the name of Jyoti Basu. He is also a great leader of the country", senior Congress leader Veerappa Moily said yesterday.

          RJD chief and Railway Minister Lalu Prasad also supported the nomination of Basu, who holds the record of India's longest serving Chief Minister. Basu headed the Left Front government in West Bengal from 1977 till 2000.

          As the controversy continued, the name of DMK supremo and Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M Karunanidhi has also come up. BSP supremo Mayawati has also demanded Bharat Ratna for party founder Kanshiram.

           

          CPI(M) criticises BJP, not opposed to Bharat Ratna for Basu 
          Kolkata (PTI): The CPI(M) on Friday accused the BJP of politicising the Bharat Ratna by proposing the award for former premier A B Vajpayee, while indicating that it was not opposed to party patriarch Jyoti Basu being conferred the country's highest civilian honour.

          "I don't know the parameters under which Bharat Ratna is awarded or whether Vajpayee fulfils that criteria. But it is definite that they want play politics over it," CPI-M politburo member Biman Bose told reporters here in reply to a question.

          Asked whether Basu should be awarded the Bharat Ratna, Bose, who is West Bengal's ruling Left Front chairman said, "I do not know the parametres on the basis of which an individual is conferred this honour. If Jyoti Basu fulfils these parametres then they (the union government) may think it over."

          Nano launch may depress two-wheeler prices: Assocham 
          New Delhi (PTI): Roll out of Tata's small car 'Nano' may lead to a 20 per cent reduction in prices of two-wheelers and a 35 per cent decline in prices of second-hand cars, industry chamber Assocham has said.

          "About 20 per cent price cut is expected in two-wheeler segment with launch of Tata-Nano," the chamber said while releasing the finding of a quick survey of 250 CEOs.

          Nano is expected to be launched close to Diwali.

          Majority of CEOs said the Tatas are expected to give a stiff challenge to two-wheeler manufactures, who would be forced to go in for product and technology innovation.

          The survey claimed that scooters and mopeds launched last year witnessed a poor response from buyers, adding that experts were sceptical about the higher engine-capacity motorcycles that entered the cost-sensitive Indian market.

          About 25 per cent of the respondents felt that the two-wheeler market has already shrunk to about 15.50 lakh units by November last year compared to over 19 lakh units a year ago. "The segment would witness a further decline as there would be various options in the four-wheeler segment with bridging of price difference," the chamber said.


          Fire and Kolkata theatres go hand in hand


          kolkata: the history of theatre in kolkata has been closely interlinked with devastating fires since as early as 1797 when the bengalee theatre was destroyed. the blaze which gutted rangmahal theatre on wednesday is an addition to an already long list. among the theatres linked to mysterious fires are those established by the british like the chowringhee theatre and the sans souci and those set up for indians, the bengalee theatre of gerashim lebedeff, the great national theatre, the minerva, the university institute, the muktangan and, above all, the star theatre. "while some of the incidents are purely accidents, some others definitely have a conspiracy behind them," said nripendra saha, former editor of the 'group theatre' magazine. the conspiracy theory exists in the case of the bengalee theatre, the first one for the bengalis and, for that matter, indians, set up by gerashim stepanovich lebedeff, a russian musician, who had come to india in 1875 to seek his fortune. the story goes that its competitor, the calcutta theatre, had infiltrated one of their men, joseph battle, into the bengalee on domtollah street where he suceeded in creating a division among the staff members. it is not exactly known whether battle himself set fire to the bengalee or masterminded its fiery end in may 1797. the historic star theatre, where the doyen of bengali theatre girish ghosh and eminent actresses like nati binodini and tarasundari were associated, founded in 1883 was also destroyed in a fire. sri ramakrishna paramhansa also attended a show, chaitanya lila , with noti binodini in the lead role directed by his disciple, girish ghosh, at the star in 1884. other greats like amritalal basu, ardhenusekhar mustafi, sisir kumar bhaduri in the earlier days and later debnarayan gupta and uttam kumar were also associated with it at different times. the theatre changed hands several times. on the night of october 13, 1991 it went up in flames. one of the greatest directors that bengal ever produced, sisir kumar bhaduri, besides thespians like manoranjan bhattacharya, durgadas bandyopadhyay and bidhayak bhattacharya were associated with the latest victim, rangmahal, established by rabi roy and satu sen in 1931. the theatre, closed for a long time was being let out for weddings and social functions. it was gutted in the wee hours yesterday. the ownership of this theatre too changed several times. down memory lane, the other two fire accidents occurred in the chowringhee theatre and sans souci where an eminent actress of the time was killed. but these cases were accidents. inaugurated on november 25, 1813, the chowringhee theatre was stated to be the best among the british theatres of calcutta of yore. prince dwarakanath tagore, the grandfather of rabindranath tagore, was its member and bought the theatre when it was in dire financial crisis. it was reduced to ashes on the night of may 31, 1839. but it was the sans souci theatre, opened on august 21, 1839 at park street where the sole death occurred in the history of fire accidents in theatres here. leech, the body and soul of the sans souci, died after her costume caught fire during the staging of a farcehandsome husband in november 1841. on december 31, 1873, the inaugural day of the great national theatre, the building was severely damaged by a fire sparked by a gas 'star light' on the stage. the muktangan and the university institute were also damaged in blazes in the 1970s and 1980s. the fires were caused by short circuits, nripendra saha said. it is significant to note that the very first theatre house here, play house, was destroyed by nawab sirajuddaulla during his invasion of calcutta in 1756.


          Workers caught in tannery tangle



          KOLKATA: The fresh drive to disconnect power and water lines of the tanneries in the Topsia-Tiljala belt has caught the workers in a bend. The prevailing mood among them is confusion and uncertainty. 


          On one hand, they apprehend that the drive, apparently a tactical move by the authorities to force more units to the new Calcutta Leather Complex at Karaidanga, may enhance the already visible trend among owners to shift base from the state. On the other, fissures have started to appear in the worker-owner camaraderie forged at the initial stages of the movement against the government's efforts to push the tanneries to the complex. That is why, some trade union leaders felt, Saturday's drive was not resisted. 


          The main reason for the divide is that as the idle time between closure and relocation gets longer, disputes regarding payment of workers' dues are coming to the fore. The Supreme Court, which ordered the relocation on environmental grounds, also laid down certain safeguards for workers. These included wages for the idle period, shifting bonus and payment of six years' salaries to every worker retrenched. This, the owners feel, is too much for them as they, too, are not sure when they would be able to start production. 


          Only the Crescent Tannery workers, after a prolonged battle at labour fora, have just managed extract the dues stipulated by the court, Calcutta Leather Tannery Workmen's Union general secretary Babu Dutta said. 


          Even as the government wants to show the apex court when the mid-October deadline comes that most of the tanneries have been moved to Karaidanga, a visit to the complex gives one no clue as when the infrastructure, including the common effluent treatment plant, would be complete. This discourages the owners to shift there. 


          The workers, too, have their own grievances regarding infrastructure. They have not only been working in the tanneries in the Tiljala-Topsia-Tangra area, but also living there. Their demands for housing and hospitals at the new complex have fallen on deaf ears.


          Kolkata, India

          by Nitai Kundu

          Summary

          The slums of Kolkata can be divided into three groups: the older ones, up to 150 years' old, in the heart of the city, are associated with early urbanization. The second group dates from the 1940s and 1950s and emerged as an outcome of industrialization-based rural–urban migration, locating themselves around industrial sites and near infra-structural arteries. The third group came into being after the independence of India and took vacant urban lands and areas along roads, canals and on marginal lands. In 2001, 1.5 million people, or one third of Kolkata's population, lived in 2011 registered and 3500 unregistered slums.

          The 1956 Slum Act defines slums as 'those areas where buildings are in any respect unfit for human habitation'. The Calcutta Municipal Council Act of 1980 defines bustees as 'an area of land not less than 700 square metres occupied by, or for the purposes of, any collection of huts or other structures used or intended to be used for human habitation'. The Central Statistics Organization defines slums as an area 'having 25 or more katcha structures, mostly of temporary nature, or 50 or more households residing mostly in katcha structures huddled together or inhabited by persons with practically no private
          latrine and inadequate public latrine and water facilities'. There is a host of different slum categories, primarily divided into two categories:

           
          Registered slums (bustees): these slums are recognized by the Calcutta Municipal Corporation (CMC) on the basis of land title; since 1980, they have been taken over by the CMC for letting/lease to slum dwellers.

           
          Unregistered slums: this comprises slums onthe land encroaching settlements.

          The bustee-type generally has some form of secure tenure or ownership rights based on land rent or lease, with structures built by the slum dwellers, or house rental/lease of structures built by third parties.

          Tenure security is, in principle, not available to the unregistered land encroaching settlements on road sides (jhupri), along canals (khaldhar) or on other vacant land (udbastu).

          It is envisaged that the number of urban poor will increase considerably in the near future due to natural growth and in-migration, combined with a lack of wellplanned and long-term intervention strategies.

          Over 40 per cent of Kolkata's slum residents have been slum dwellers for two generations or longer, and more than half originate from the Kolkata hinterland. With the majority engaged in the informal sector, with average monthly earnings of between 500 and 1700 rupees and a household size of five to six persons, some three-quarters of the Kolkata slum population are below the poverty line. 

          The standard of living of the slum dwellers caused concern even during colonial rule. For a long time, slums were treated as an eyesore and a nuisance to be dealt with for reasons of safety, security, and the health and hygiene of the urban elite. Policy interventions focused mostly on clearance and removal. The First, Second and Third Five-Year Plans laid emphasis on slum eradication and removal. Various attempts were made to address the issue in alternative ways; but all failed for different reasons.

          The Environment Improvement in Urban Sector (EIUS) scheme, in operation since 1974, has been partially successful in improving the living environment of slum dwellers; but it has not helped in preventing the growth of new slums through migration or natural increase. The scheme suffers from lack of community involvement in planning, implementation and monitoring of the programme. Another initiative that has generally been effective in reducing urban poverty is the National Slum Development Programme (NSDP).

          Although some considerable successes have been achieved, there is a long way to go for Kolkata in terms of addressing the issues related to urban poverty and slums. There is an urgent need to establish clear long-term strategies that address such issues as: 

           land titles in bustees;

           unauthorized new slums around canal and roads;

          greater effectiveness of urban poverty-eradication programmes;

           public awareness-building programmes on slum population;

           the role of each actor and stakeholder;

           poverty reduction approaches to slum improvement;

           inadequate municipal institutional arrangements, including coordination of the activities of various actors.

          This summary has been extracted from:
          http://www.allvoices.com/contributed-news/5009455-kolkata-slums-destroyed-in-devastating-fire
          UN-Habitat (2003) Global Report on Human Settlements 2003, The Challenge of Slums, Earthscan, London; Part IV: 'Summary of City Case Studies', pp195-228.



          Tangra, Calcutta

          From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

          Coordinates22°33′N 88°23′E

          Tangra is a region in east Kolkata that traditionally housed a large number of tanneries owned by people of Hakka Chinese origin. "47 South Tangra Road", may be the most confusing postal address, as it used to cover the whole of Chinatown Tangra with over 350 tanneries. Most of the standing structures have been built, over many years, by the industrious Hakka Chinese, upon marshy and reclaimed low lying land. Over the past several decades, it has served as the location of Calcutta's Chinatown. This is not a coincidence; the Hakka Chinese of Calcutta have gradually turned this part of the Kolkata into an important destination for sourcing finished and semi-finished leather. The Hakka Chinese specialized in the manufacture of leather and turned it into one of the major industries of West Bengal, providing employment to tens of thousands of local inhabitants. In addition to the huge volume of exports to the developing and developed countries, finished leather is supplied to the major shoe and leather goods manufacturers all over the country. Many made-to-order shoe shops in Kolkata are also run by enterpreneurs from this community.

          Food from Tangra is a distinct variety of traditional Hakka Chinese cuisine adapted to Indian ingredients and the Bengali palate. This has spread to the rest of India, along with the recipes earlier unique to Tangra. Tangra is now the most popular destination for Chinese food. Chinese food sold in Tangra restaurants are now known all over the world as 'Hakka Style" Chinese food.

          Kolkata Chinatown is changing rapidly. The population is no longer renewed by waves of migration and many traditional professions such as dentistry, laundry and tannery are no longer the preserve of the Chinese. The West Bengal government, under direction from the Supreme Court, recently moved all tanneries to Bantala, a suburb in the east of Kolkata.

          The success of "Hakka style" Chinese food in the rest of India encouraged a migration of many Chinese families to other cities as the economic fortunes of Tangra decayed. Many landmark Chinese eateries, including Nanking, Waldorf, Peiping and Fat Mama have closed or changed hands and fortunes. The once prosperous Calcutta Chinese community is now clearly in decline. However, a boom in Tangra's unique Indian-Chinese food is attracting a lot of attention these days and the cuisine will probably live on in Kolkata and in the global Indian Diaspora.

          [edit]External links





          2006 Kolkata leather factory fire
          Date November 22, 2006
          Time 2:30 IST
          Location West Bengal, India
          Casualties
          10 dead
          18 injured

          The 2006 Kolkata leather factory fire was a deadly industrial fire that occurred in West Bengal, India, on 22 November, 2006. The fire broke out in a leather bag factory located in the Tannix International, Topsia, in the South 24 Parganas district in Greater Kolkata area, and generated a wave of criticism of the poor safety standards in place among the country's sweatshops.

          The industrial fire claimed the lives of at least ten people, who were unable to escape because the illegal factory's doors were locked shut. Authorities, in response to local residents' angry criticism, admitted that the emergency response to the accident was substandard. Two separate investigations were launched. One inquiry focused on the fire itself, while the other sought to ascertain criminal responsibility for the disaster as well as the operation of the illegal factory.[1] The results of both are either pending or have yet to be released to the general public.







          Contents

           [hide]

          [edit]Background

          Investigators confirmed that the site of the fire had been used as an illegal factory to manufacture leather bags.[1] The factory was located on the third floor of a four-story building,[2][3] which also featured residential units.[4] Investigators determined that the first and second floors of the structure housed additional illegal factories.[3] The factory destroyed in the fire was found to be owned and operated by Tenex Exports,[3] and all of the people who were killed or injured in the fire slept in the factory at night, a situation that is not considered unusual in India. There was had just one emergency exit, and 40 workers were housed in the structure at the time of the fire,[5] and the owner had locked the factory at night to prevent workers from running away with leather goods.[6] The building was located in the Tannix International, Topsia, in the South 24 Parganas district of Greater Kolkata region.[2][5]

          [edit]Event and emergency response

          The interior of the factory after the fire had been extinguished.

          The fire broke out in the factory at around 2:30 IST,[2] as workers slept. Once they became aware of the blaze, the employees found they were unable to break through the factory's locked doors. Five fire tenderswere sent to the scene,[2] but by the time they arrived, local residents had broken down two locked gates and already rescued the surviving workers.[3] These impromptu Rescue efforts were delayed however, when an individual carrying keys to open the door nervously dropped them while attempting to open the gate.[3] At least 10 people were dead by the time rescuers reached the factory's interior,[7] with a further eighteen injured. The survivors, many suffering from burns over 70 percent of their bodies, were taken to the National Medical College and Hospital, where victims had to be left on the floor due to a shortage of beds.[8] The hospital did not have a burns unit, and the only treatments available at the hospital were ointments and saline drips. The patients were eventually moved to other hospitals.[5] Local MLA Javed Khan later said that the death toll is actually at least twelve, but there has been no official confirmation of this.[2][9] The Rapid Action Force was also deployed to maintain calm.[2][8]

          [edit]Criticisms of the emergency response

          People living in the vicinity of the illegal factory said that the number of deaths might have been reduced had the fire service responded promptly. They claimed that the fire brigade failed to send personnel or equipment to the scene until more than an hour after the brigade first received word of the fire. Residents also claimed that it was only after the police arrived and requested fire service backup that any help was sent.[2] In addition, some on the scene reported an inadequate number of ambulances.[9] The city's mayor admitted to this lapse the following morning.[9] Local people also complained that the victims should never have been taken to the Calcutta National Medical College, but that they should have been transported directly to hospitals with burns units.[10]

          [edit]Investigations

          [edit]Accident investigation

          An investigation has been launched to determine the cause of the fire as well as the reason the building had been locked from the outside.[10]To this end, the building was inspected by the KMC, and was subsequently scheduled to be demolished on Thursday, November 23. However, the structure is standing as of 2007.[5] Although no actual cause of the fire has been established, it has been noted that large quantities ofinflammable materials, such as adhesives, were stored inside the building.[2] It was also revealed that the factory experienced a similar fire two years previously, but on that occasion there were no fatalities.[6]

          [edit]Criminal investigation

          A separate criminal investigation focused on the illegal factory itself.[1] Almost all factories and homes in the area were illegal and unauthorised,[5] and do not follow building codes and sanctions.[6] Mayor Bikash Ranjan Bhattacharya said action would be taken against the owners of the factory and house, and Superintendent of Police of South 24 Parganas S. N. Gupta said that the owners of the building would be arrested.[8] Investigation has shown that the Kolkata Municipal Corporation (KMC) issued notices to the building on three separate occasions, in 1988, 1989, and 1992, yet took no further action. It has been shown, however, that the KMC also approved trade licences for two businesses to operate from the building.[5] The owner of the building, Khurshid Alam, has had a police complaint filed against him by the fire department for illegal construction charges. Mohammed Sagir Ahmed and Mohammed Asif, the owners of Tenex Exports, also face related charges.[3] Both investigations are ongoing.

          [edit]Aftermath

          The day after this tragedy, workers in the unorganized leather industry of Topsia area held protest rallies demanding compensation for the relatives of the deceased workers, better working conditions and a probe into the fire mishap.[11] The mayor of Kolkata convened an all-party meeting to discuss the incident and also promised to initiate a drive demolish illegal constructions in the area.[11] The labour inspectors inspected the building and declared the factory as illegal.[11] Even though the building was declared illegal and unsafe, a month later, the police raided the house and found that another leather factory was operating behind closed doors in the ground floor of the building.[12] The civic officials issued a notice to stop any work in the building.[12] Though local residents alleged that clandestine work started in the building with the help of local MLA, Javen Khan, Khan himself blamed it rather on the police.[12]

          In 2008, two more fire mishaps occurred in the leather industries in the area, one in the month of March and the other in June: a total of nine people got injured in these two incidents.[13] Even though fire safety licenses and insurances for the workers of the leather factories were made mandatory after the fire incident of 2006, none of the authorities—the municipal corporation, the services department of the state government, and the police—ensured that these were actually followed by the factories.[13] The local residents claimed that the owner of the factory that was impacted in the fire incident of 2006, now operates from another address of the same area.[13] According to fire brigade officials, the Topsia area along with nearby Tiljala and Tangra forms the most fire-prone area of the city, and that around three to four fires break out every week, though they do not get reported in the media as there is no loss of life.[13]

          [edit]References

          1. a b c "Nine Die, 18 Injured in Kolkata Factory Fire - Irna"Islamic Republic News Agency. 2006-11-22. Retrieved 2009-07-14.
          2. a b c d e f g h "Fire in Kolkata factory, 9 dead"CNN-IBN. 2006-11-22. Archived from the original on 2009-07-22. Retrieved 2006-12-17.
          3. a b c d e f "Locked in to be burnt to death—Nine killed in illegal factory in illegal house". The Telegraph, Calcutta. 2006-11-23. Retrieved 2009-07-13.
          4. ^ "Fire in Kolkata leather factory kills 9 people."ExpressIndia.com. 2006-11-22. Archived from the original on 2009-07-22. Retrieved 2006-12-17.
          5. a b c d e f "Factory Fire in Kolkata Causes 9 Deaths"India Daily. Archived from the original on 2009-07-22. Retrieved 2006-12-19.
          6. a b c "Locked-in workers battle death by fire"Express India. 2006-11-23. Retrieved 2006-12-19.
          7. ^ "The men who died young"Calcutta Telegraph. 2006-11-24. Retrieved 2006-12-19.
          8. a b c "Leather factory fire kills nine"India eNews. 2006-11-22. Retrieved 2006-12-19.
          9. a b c "12 charred to death in factory fire"The India Tribune. 2006-11-22. Retrieved 2006-12-19.
          10. a b "Locked-in workers charred in Topsia"The Times of India. 2006-11-23. Retrieved 2006-12-19.
          11. a b c "Fire lights spark of protest—Workers march in sweatshop zone's first rally". The Telegraph, Calcutta. 2006-11-24. Archived from the original on 2009-07-22. Retrieved 2009-07-13.
          12. a b c Imran Ali Siddiqui (2006-12-30). "Bag unit sealed". The Telegraph, Calcutta. Retrieved 2009-07-13.
          13. a b c d "Sweatshop belt plays with fire & life—Lessons from 2006 Topsia Road tragedy forgotten; illegal businesses continue to thrive". The Telegraph, Calcutta. 2008-06-17. Retrieved 2009-07-13.

          Hawkers in Kolkata

          From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

          Mother Teresa Sarani (Park Street)
          Vendors selling flowers in a road-side market

          Hawkers in Kolkata numbering 275,000 generated business worth Rs. 8,772 crore (around 2 billionU.S. dollars) in 2005.[1] In Kolkata, formerly known as Calcutta, in the Indian state of West Bengal, almost 80 per cent of the pavements are encroached by hawkers and illegal settlers.[2]In many countries, hawkers use pavements or other public places to retail their goods or services but in Kolkata the magnitude has drawn special attention of administrators and law courts.

          Contents

           [hide]

          [edit]Background

          The population of Kolkata urban agglomeration grew from 1,510,000 in 1901 to 4,670,000 in 1951 to 9,194,000 in 1981.[3] Kolkata did not draw in people from rural areas by offering a better quality of life. As in any other Indian city, the immigrants found poverty in Kolkata as severe and dehumanising as in the villages, but was offered a relatively quick opportunity of new income through placement in the urban economy. With the partition of India in 1947, the metropolitan cities of Kolkata and Delhiwere flooded by displaced persons or refugees from Pakistan. The Union government at Delhi, with better resources at its command, handled the task of rehabilitation faster and more comprehensively, than the state government in Kolkata could accomplish. Left largely to themselves the refugees in Kolkata gradually secured their placements in the urban economy.[3]

          The 1951 census found that only 33.2 percent of Kolkata's inhabitants were city-born, the rest were immigrants: 12.3 percent were from elsewhere in West Bengal, 26.6 percent from other Indian states, and 26.9 percent from East Pakistan. In 1981, the Government of West Bengal estimated the total number of persons displaced from East Bengal to the state to be around 8 million or one sixth of the total population of the state.[4] Several million refugees settled in the outskirts of Kolkata.[5]

          The percentage of migrants in Kolkata's population has been declining since the 1950s, though around a third of the population still consists of fresh migrants. Kolkata is gradually attaining a state of saturation.[6]It has also been affected by economic decline resulting from industrial sickness. In 2005, West Bengal headed the list of states with sick units.[5]The overall economic scenario is highlighted by the growing number of pavement dwellers. Kolkata had 48,802 pavement dwellers in 1971 and 55,571 in 1985, according to Census and/or KMDA figures. Around two thirds are from West Bengal and the rest from outside the state.[6]

          While the economy of Kolkata has been sliding backwards in many respects, there has been remarkable expansion in certain areas – real estateinformation technology and retail trade. Big shopping centres have come up, and along with it there has been a large increase in small shops and pavement stalls.[5][7]


          Political Actions

          With hawkers occupying large portions of the pavements, in the sixties the state government, then controlled by the Congress Party, launched Operation Hawker and tried to remove hawkers from the streets of Kolkata. The Communist Party of India (Marxist), then in the opposition, organised the hawkers in active protest. Soon thereafter, the Congress Party was out of power in the state. Later, when the CPI(M) was firmly in saddle as leader of the Left Front for around two decades, it launched Operation Sunshine in 1996. Officers of Kolkata Municipal Corporation, cadres of the CPI(M) along with police battalions demolished the side walk stalls of thousands of hawkers. Such stalls had lined the city's thoroughfares for nearly three decades. This time the hawkers were mobilised by opposition leaders such as Mamata Banerjee but the Left Front remained firm in its conviction to remove hawkers.[8]However, in the face of protests, the municipal administration and the police allowed the hawkers to reoccupy gradually the pavements of streets from which they had been cleared. The Calcutta Hawker Sangram Committee, a union of more than 32 local hawkers' associations formed in the beforemath of Operation Sunshine, took the leadership to reclaim the footpaths [Bandyopadhyay Ritajyoti (2009): Archiving from Below: The Case of the Mobilised Hawkers in Calcutta, Sociological Research Online, Volume 14, Issue 5,<http://www.socresonline.org.uk/14/5/7.html>.See also, Bandyopadhyay Ritajyoti (2009): Hawkers' Movement in Kolkata, Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 44, No.17]. The situation has come to such a pass that according to a deputy commissioner of Kolkata Police, 80 per cent of Kolkata's pavements are encroached by hawkers and illegal settlers. Pedestrians are forced to use the roads because there is hardly any space on the pavements for walking, and once people are getting used to walking on the streets, they continue to do so even if the side walks are vacant.[2]Some reports suggest that the hawkers have made a comeback on the streets of Kolkata during the period 2000-2005 whenTrinamool Congress was in power in Kolkata Corporation.[9] Bandyopadhyay (2009)has recently argued that the Hawker Sangram Committee has subsequently come to occupy a central position in the governance of the realm of pavement-hawking through the creation and maintenance of an archival database that articulates the entrepreneurial capacity of the 'poor hawker' and his ability to deliver goods and services at low-cost. The significance of the Hawker Sangram Committee's archive is that, it enables the organisation to form a critique of the exclusionary discourses on the hawker, mostly propagated by a powerful combination of a few citizens' associations, the judiciary and the press. The paper also documents how the successful mobilisation of a population group like the hawkers is marked by the virtual destruction of a pre-existing archive on the other group of 'encroachers' of the pavement space, the pavement dwellers.

          [edit]Legal action

          With the politicians dilly-dallying, the matter rolled on to the courts as public interest litigation. In 1996, Kolkata High Court asked the state government to submit a detailed report on pavement encroachment. In 1998, another case demanding rehabilitation of hawkers was moved in the court. In 2003, the high court asked the state government to state its stand on hawkers. In 2005, the state government informed the high court that a uniform policy on rehabilitation of hawkers was underway. In 2007, the high court found that its 1996 order was not implemented.[10]

          Commenting on a petition filed by environmentalist Subhas Dutta in 2004, the division bench of Chief Justice V.S. Sirpurkar and Soumitra Sen observed in 2006, that the hawker menace was growing like cancer. It was impossible for people to walk on the roads, forget about footpaths.[11]

          The advocate general informed the high court that the state government had drawn out a plan regarding the hawkers. The highlights of the plan were earmarking of hawker free zone, creating some hawking zones, setting time limits for hawking, banning erection of permanent structures, keeping two thirds of pavement free of hawkers, replacing polythene sheets with colourful umbrellas, removing of hawkers from 50 yards (46 m) of crossings, and issuing licences to existing hawkers only.[12]

          [edit]Municipal Corporation

          KMC had conducted Operation Sunshine in 1996 to remove hawkers from Gariahat and Shyambazar. Following the hawker removal drive, the KMC commissioner, Asim Barman, had issued a notification imposing certain restrictions on the movement of hawkers on 21 streets in the city.[13]

          Bikash Bhattacharya, Mayor of Kolkata, has said that hawkers would be allowed to stay on all pavements across the city and they would be allowed to occupy a third of the pavements along the streets but they would not be allowed to occupy space within a 50-metre radius of road crossings or build any structures.[9]

          According to the Hawker Sangram Committee, "Hawkers are exploited by the agents of trade union leaders, politicians, police, civic councillors. They have to pay to earn their bread." The hawkers pay Rs. 266 crores as bribe. This is around 3 per cent of the business. The Committee says, "We are willing to pay rent or some other form of tax to the civic body if we get the right to conduct business. Identity cards will protect us from extortion by multiple agencies," [1]

          There are several unions or associations of hawkers, such as Calcutta Hawkers' Men Union and Bengal Hawkers Association.

          [edit]References

          1. a b Ganguly, Deepankar. "Hawkers stay as Rs. 265 crore talks"The Telegraph, 30 November 2006. Retrieved 2008-02-16.
          2. a b "Oh Kolkata! Pavements are for pedestrians"A Better KolkataThe Statesman, 10 June 2002. Retrieved 2008-02-16.
          3. a b Chakraborty, Satyesh C., The Growth of Calcutta in the Twentieth Century, in Calcutta:The Living City, Vol II, Edited by Chaudhuri, Sukanta, 1990/2005, Page 7, Table 2, ISBN 019 563697 X
          4. ^ Nilanjana Chatterjee, The East Bengal Refugees, A lesson in Survival, in Calcutta:The Living City, Vol II, p. 70.
          5. a b c Datta, Bhabatosh, The Economy of Calcutta, Today and Tomorrow, in Calcutta:The Living City, Vol II, pp. 96-104.
          6. a b Ghosh, Ambikaprasad, The Demography of Calcutta, in Calcutta:The Living City, Vol II, p. 51, 57.
          7. ^ "'Bengal fifth most attractive destination'"The Hindu Business Line, 19 February 2008. Retrieved 2008-02-16.
          8. ^ Edited by Ananya Roy, and Nezar Alsayyad. "Urban Informality"6. The Gentleman's City. Business and Economics. Retrieved 2008-02-27.
          9. a b Ganguly, Deepankar. "So long sunshine, hello hawkers"The Telegraph, 23 February 2006. Retrieved 2008-02-16.
          10. ^ "Glare on hawkers and car chaos - Court seeks status report with time frame for pavements and traffic flow"The Telegraph, 13 March 2007. Retrieved 2008-02-16.
          11. ^ "Free roads or court trouble - Hawkers like cancer, says chief justice"The Telegraph, 20 May 2006. Retrieved 2008-02-16.
          12. ^ "A roadmap for hawkers off roads"The Telegraph, 22 March 2007. Retrieved 2008-02-16.
          13. ^ "State to regulate hawker movement in Kolkata". The Statesman, 28 July 2005. Retrieved 2008-02-16.

          Bandyopadhyay Ritajyoti (2009): Archiving from Below: The Case of the Mobilised Hawkers in Calcutta, Sociological Research Online, Volume 14, Issue 5, <http://www.socresonline.org.uk/14/5/7.html>.

          Bandyopadhyay Ritajyoti (2009): Hawkers' Movement in Kolkata, Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. 44, No.17.
          1. What exactly is the Unique ID project? - CIOL News Reports

             - 2 visits - 27/06/09
            26 Jun 2009 ... At that time, the UPA government had said that unique identity (UID)number of each individual would remain a permanent identifier right ...
            www.ciol.com/News/News-Reports/What...Unique-ID.../0/ - Cached - Similar - 
          2. Unique ID for all Indian citizens soon | iGovernment.in

            15 Jan 2010 ... The Unique Identity (UID) project seeks to assign a UID number to each individual in the country that would remain a permanent identifier ...
            igovernment.in › eGov - Cached - 
          3. Unique ID number for every Indian citizen by 2011

            7 Feb 2009 ... Financial express latest business and finance news: Unique ID number for every Indian citizen by 2011.
            www.financialexpress.com/.../Unique-ID-number.../420169/ - Angola -Cached - Similar - 
          4. Your unique identity number may become your mobile number ...

            22 Aug 2009 ... Your unique identity number may become your mobile number ... is studying if the unique identity number (UID) could be converted into mobile ...
            economictimes.indiatimes.com/...unique-identity-number...number/.../4921286.cms -Cached - 
          5. The Unique Identity number — putting all eggs in one basket ...

            8 Jul 2009 ... The project provides a unique identity number, something like the US social security number, to India's billion-plus citizens.
            blogs.reuters.com/.../the-unique-identity-number-putting-all-our-eggs-in-one-basket/ -Cached - Similar - 
          6. Unique Identification Number - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

             - 28 Feb
            Unique Identification Number (UID) is a recently finalized initiative by the Government of India to create and manage a centralized identification system ...
            en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unique_Identification_Number - Cached - 
          7. Nandan Nilekani | Unique Identity Numbers | Smart Cards | PAN ...

            16 Jul 2009 ... New Delhi, Jul 16: Nandan Nilekani will aim at providing unique number to all Indians. The unique ID numbers will not substitude other ...
            news.oneindia.in/.../nilekani-to-issue-uid-numbers-not-smart-cards.html -Cached - Similar - 
          8. Unique identity number looks to define privacy - dnaindia.com

            20 Sep 2009 ... You can ask whether x is x? And the only answer we will give is yes or no, says Nandan Nilekani.
            www.dnaindia.com › India - Cached - Similar - 
          9. Delhiites may get unique ID number within three years

            3 Sep 2009 ... Delhiites may get their individual unique ID numbers in three years, Unique Identification Authority of India Chairman Nandan Nilekani said ...
            ibnlive.in.com › India - Cached - Similar - 
          10. [PDF] 

            Does India need a Unique Identity Number?

            File Format: PDF/Adobe Acrobat
            production of unique identification number for verification can happen with some latency. What have other countries done on the national ID front? ...
            www.wipro.com/.../wcs-opinions-does-india-need-a-unique-identity-number.pdf - 
          11. News results for Unique Identity Number

            Unique identification scheme for all in Mumbai, even those from ...‎ - 7 hours ago
            ... would be eligible to get a number under the central government's Unique ... for Mumbai on behalf of the Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDAI).
            Times of India - 4 related articles »

            1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Next
            Presented at National Seminar on 'Migration and Its Impact on Indian State and Democracy' – 13 March 2009,
            Dept of Politics & Public Administration – University of Pune
            Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees – Idea of West Bengal at Stake – Mohit Ray 1
            Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees – Idea of West Bengal at Stake
            Mohit Ray
            Mohit Ray, PhD (Engineering) is an independent environmental consultant and visiting faculty in School of Environmental
            Studies, Jadavpur University. He has been involved in human rights movement for last three decades and now leads a
            campaign for the rights of minorities in Bangladesh. He can be contacted at mohitray@hotmail.com
            I
            Idea of West Bengal: Eroded from the Very Emergence
            West Bengal was created as a non-Muslim majority state in 1947. On 20 June 1947, Bengal
            Legislative Assembly got divided into East Bengal Legislative Assembly and West Bengal
            Legislative Assembly. In the West Bengal Legislative Assembly all the non-Muslim
            assembly members including the Communists favoured for the creation of this truncated
            state.1 One of the two Communist members was Shri Jyoti Basu. After the experience of ten
            years of Muslim-dominated coalition rule in Bengal between 1937 and 1947 and a series of
            riots for last three decades, particularly the Noakahli pogrom, the Hindu Bengal was not
            ready to go with Pakistan2. A well-known Left historian had to comment about the
            September riot in 1918 in Kolkata, which took place followed by a publication in Anglo-
            Indian newspaper the Indian Daily News, as
            '(that riot) anticipated many of the trends in future Muslim rioting in Calcutta – the
            mosque as an important rallying point, the upcountrymen as the main component of
            the violent crowd, the Marwari merchanr as favourite target of attack, and the
            vernacular press as the main forum for expressing communal animosities'.3, 4 .
            The idea of West Bengal was to have a secular democratic entity quite different from what
            Pakistan was thought to be. Muslim-majority Pakistan and later Bangladesh became Islamic
            countries while West Bengal emerged as a part of the country with non-religious
            constitution.
            No Exchange of Population
            There was no exchange of population in Bengal as it happened for Punjab. Though Punjab
            passed through the initial months of mayhem, for following 60 years there has been no
            Hindu-Muslim problem or Sikh-Muslim problem in either parts of Punjab. East Punjab
            (Indian part of Punjab) had 33.09% of Muslims in 1941 which got reduced to 1.8% in 1951
            1 As per the plan, on 20 June the issue of Bengal partition was decided upon by the members of the Assembly.
            Several rounds of voting were held. On the question of joining the 'present constituent Assembly' (ie, the
            Indian Union), the division of the joint session of the House stood at 126 votes against the move and 90 votes
            in favour. Then the members of the Muslim-majority areas (East Bengal) in a separate session passed a motion
            by 106-35 votes against partitioning Bengal and for joining a new Constituent Assembly (ie, Pakistan) as a
            whole. This was followed by the separate meeting of the members of the non-Muslim-majority areas (West
            Bengal) who by a division of 58-21 voted for partition of the province. It must be mentioned that a single
            majority vote in favour of partition by either notionally divided half of the Assembly would have decided the
            division of the province under the rule. (http://banglapedia.search.com.bd/HT/P_0101.htm)
            2 Hiranmoy Karlekar, Bangladesh – The Next Afghanisthan, pp 38, Sage Publications 2005
            3 Suranjan Das, Communal riots in Bengal, 1905-1947 pp 74-75, Oxford University Press 1993.
            4 Interestingly same pattern is still followed, as on 6-9 February 2009, the Muslim rioters targeted the
            Statesman, one of the oldest dailies in the country, in Kolkata because of a published article. The violence
            continued for 3 days, however no press or electronic media reported, the Bengali intellectuals remained silent.
            Presented at National Seminar on 'Migration and Its Impact on Indian State and Democracy' – 13 March 2009,
            Dept of Politics & Public Administration – University of Pune
            Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees – Idea of West Bengal at Stake – Mohit Ray 2
            and has not increased much.5 In fact it was B. R. Ambedkar who categorically stated long
            before partition in 1940 that
            'That the transfer of minorities is the only lasting remedy for communal peace is
            beyond doubt'6.
            The Muslim population which stood at 29.5% in 1941 in West Bengal got reduced to 19.5%
            in 1951, has shot back to 25.5% in 2001. We shall later deal with these figures in a greater
            detail and its significance for West Bengal. Going back to the advise of B.R. Ambedkar on
            this issue of numbers:
            'What do these figures indicate? ….. This distribution of the Muslim population, in
            terms of communal problem, means that while without Pakistan the communal
            problem in India involves 6 ½ crores of Muslims, with the creation of Pakistan it will
            involve only 2 crores of Muslims. Is this to be no consideration for Hindus who want
            communal peace? To me it seems that if Pakistan does not solve the communal
            problem within Hindustan, It substantially reduces its proportion…..'7
            Nehru-Liaquat Treaty 1950 and Two Resignations
            After the partition of India in 1947, within a year the situation started to settle down in
            Western border. It is generally expressed that Eastern part was relatively calm, and initial
            migration on both sides of Bengal were expected to stop in the coming years. But the
            situation in East Pakistan (and now in Bangladesh) always remained as a status of 'gentle
            push' even when there is no major pogrom. A simple method is to harass the Hindu
            neighbours, tease their women, violate the sanctity of their household by polluting their
            worshipping areas. Many a vivid accounts are available in Bengali writings.8
            On 8th April 1950 Jawaharlal Nehru, the Prime Minister of India and Liaquat Ali khan,
            Prime Minister of Pakistan, signed an agreement between two countries to 'ensure to the
            minorities throughout its territory complete equality..' which included 'freedom of
            movement'. Shyamaprasad Mukherjee, the minister of Industries and Supply in Nehru's
            cabinet, resigned over this issue. In his statement in the Parliament on 14 April, 1950, he
            said
            'The fact thus remains that inspite of two Inter – Dominion Agreements as many as
            16 to 20 lakhs of Hindus were sent away to India from East Bengal. About a million
            of uprooted Hindus had also to come away from Sind. During this period a large
            number of Muslims also came away from Pakistan mainly influenced by economic
            considerations. The economy of West Bengal received a rude shock and we
            continued as helpless spectators of a grim tragedy.
            'Hindus will continue to come away in large numbers and those who have come will
            not be prepared to go back. On the other hand, Muslim who had gone away will now
            return and in our determination to implement the agreement the Muslims will not
            leave India. Our economy will thus be shattered and possible conflict within our
            country will be greater.'
            Like Ambedkar's prophetic comment, Shyama Prasad's comment is true for today. We shall
            discuss more about it later.
            Within a few months another minister from Pakistan government also resigned. Mr.
            Jogendra Nath Mandal, the minister of Law and Labour, of Liaqut Ali Khan's cabinet sent
            5 Census data in Religious Demography of India – Centre for Policy Studies Chennai, 2003
            6, B.R.Ambedkar, Pakistan or Partition of India, pp 116, Babashaeb Ambedkar Writings and Speeches Vol8,
            Education Department, Government of Maharashtra, 1990.
            7 Ibid pp 118
            8 Prafulla Chakrabarti, The Marginal Men, Lumierre Books, Kalyani, 1990
            Presented at National Seminar on 'Migration and Its Impact on Indian State and Democracy' – 13 March 2009,
            Dept of Politics & Public Administration – University of Pune
            Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees – Idea of West Bengal at Stake – Mohit Ray 3
            his resignation on 8 October 1950. Mr Jogendra Nath Mandal was the leader of Scheduled
            Castes in Bengal who was the flag bearer of Scheduled Caste –Muslim unity in Bengal.9
            After partition he was rewarded with a Ministership in Pakistan cabinet. After riots in 1950,
            such a trustworthy person of Muslim League and a minister of the country had to run away
            from his promised heaven within three years to the 'Brahminical' Hindustan and send his
            resignation from there. Some excerpts from his resignation letter can be useful for this
            discussion and for the proponents of Dalit-Muslim unity of today. Mr. Mandal wrote:
            'Now this being the overall picture of Pakistan so far as the Hindus are concerned, I
            shall not be unjustified in stating that Hindus of Pakistan have to all intents and
            purposes been rendered "Stateless" in their own houses. They have no other fault
            than that they profess Hindu religion.'
            Mr. Mandal foresaw the bleak future
            'After anxious and prolonged struggle I have to come to the conclusion that Pakistan
            is no place for Hindus to live in and that their future is darkened by the ominous
            shadow of conversion or liquidation. The bulk of the upper class Hindus and
            politically conscious Scheduled Castes have left East Bengal. The Hindus who will
            continue to stay in that accursed province for that matter in Pakistan will, I am
            afraid, by gradual stages and in a planned manner be either converted to Islam or
            completely exterminated.'
            Two leaders of with so vast ideological differences shared this in common, a bleak future.
            But the mainstream political parties, Congress and Left and the refugees themselves ignored
            it to pave the way for today's scenario.
            Leftists Control of Refugee Movement and Stoicism of Upper Caste Refugees
            The refugees in '50s were mostly from Caste Hindus. They were sure that they had no future
            in Pakistan and left for good. Even that meant staying in a thatched hut on a marshy land
            leaving the huge farm house in East Bengal. Their desperation for a good living in this new
            land made the refugee movement slowly more violent. The Communists used this anger to
            take control of this movement. A very detailed description of events have been documented
            by the historian Prafulla Chakraboty.10 The Left leadership could channelise the movement
            to their 'anti-imperialistic' goal, suppressing the atrocities of Islamic rule in East Pakistan.
            So the UCRC (United Central Refugee Council) processions started to raise slogans totally
            irrelevant to refugee problem, like the slogan against Imperialism in Korea or slogan for
            peace not war and against Anglo-American imperialism.11. Not only that, one UCRC
            convention in 1952 adopted a list of resolutions which included:
            'vii) Exploitation of the country by foreign powers and discrimination against Russia
            and China in the field of international trade must be ended
            vii) Equipment should be imported from Russia for the improvement of indigeneous
            heavy industries.'12
            9 Mr Mandal said in a meeting in Delhi on 5 November, 1946 – 'The scheduled castes will prefer to live with
            freedom and dignity under Muslims or other nations rather living under Hindus'. Or 'I bow down my head to
            Quaid-e-Azam Jinnah, President of the Muslim League, for his sacrifice for the cause of Scheduled Caste'.
            From Mahapran Jogendranath – Jagadish Mandal Vol1 pp 221 & 239. Quoted in Bharat Bivajan
            Jogendranath O Ambedkar – Bipadbhanjan Biswas, 2003 and Muslim Rajniti O Jogendranath Mandaler
            Padatyag – Debojyoti Roy, 2008.
            10 Prafulla Chakrabarti, The Marginal Men, Lumierre Books, Kalyani, 1990; Besides the description of
            different events, the book contains a specific section titled 'Refugee Power and the Left' pp 329-404
            11 Ibid pp 94.
            12 Ibid pp 142
            Presented at National Seminar on 'Migration and Its Impact on Indian State and Democracy' – 13 March 2009,
            Dept of Politics & Public Administration – University of Pune
            Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees – Idea of West Bengal at Stake – Mohit Ray 4
            The Left-influenced refugee movement not only suppressed the continuous harassment of
            the Hindus in East Pakistan, they even went ahead in support of Pakistan. On 18 October
            1952, UCRC meeting at Wellington Square condemned Shyama Prasad Mukherjee for
            demanding sanctions against Pakistan. 13 On 7 April 1953, UCRC had a big demonstration
            and presented a charter of demands to the West Bengal Legislative Assembly. Significantly
            it had one of the demands as 'Rehabilitation of displaced Muslims and grant of interim relief
            to them'14, but no mention of refugees themselves for safely returning to East Pakistan in
            accordance with Nehru-Liaquat Pact. The betrayal of the upper caste refugees about their
            own people in East Pakistan ensured the future illegal migration and continuous flow of
            today's refugees, who are mostly what is considered as Scheduled Castes by Indian
            Constitution. This caste difference sealed the fate of the Hindu refugees for later years, an
            expression of upper caste Hindu leadership in Left, right and centre and their indifference.
            The one-way flow of Hindu refugees continued during the existence of East Pakistan till
            1971. Except in 1964 when some riots took place in West Bengal as retaliation to major
            rioting against Hindus in East Pakistan15, West Bengal accepted the fate of Hindus in East
            Pakistan as normal. Throughout 60's and 70's, the political scenario in West Bengal was a
            race towards a communist revolution. The politically conscious people of different left
            stands were busy in engaging in violent actions against class enemies to bring revolution.
            The leftists slowly have conquered the total intellectual gamut of Bengali Hindus. The
            situations of the Hindus in East Pakistan never became any issue of discussion amongst left.
            Nobody mentioned that even after massive migration of the Hindu refugees in West Bengal,
            the proportion of Muslim population is on the rise.
            Bangladesh War and the end of the legal Refugees
            Awami League won the election in East Pakistan and Sheikh Mujibur Rahaman declared
            independence on 26 March 1971. It was one of the quickest liberation struggles in history,
            thanks to Indian intervention. However Pakistan army carried out a genocide within nine
            months. Though many Bengali Muslims were killed, there was a plan to kill as many Hindus
            as can be done. Hamoodur Rahaman Commission, chaired by Hamoodur Rahaman, Chief
            Justic of Pakistan, revealed explosive documents which include written order to kill
            Hindus.16 R. J. Rummel , the researcher on killings by the state authorities, described a
            chilling gendercidal ritual, reminiscent of Nazi procedure towards Jewish Males:
            "In what became province-wide acts of genocide, Hindus were sought out and killed
            on the spot. As a matter of course, soldiers would check males for the obligated
            circumcision among Moslems. If circumcised, they might live; if not, sure death."17
            Bangladesh was liberated mostly on the dead bodies of Hindu Bengalis. Then there were
            nearly 10 million refugees, about 13% of then East Pakistan's populations. There were
            6797615 refugees in the government camps and 3101660 were on their own as per
            13 Ibid pp 143
            14 Ibid pp 151
            15 1964 pogrom against Hindus started in East Pakistan after the alleged theft of Prophet Mohammad's hair
            from Hazaratbal Mosque in Kashmir, 2000 kilometers away from East Pakistan and it had nothing to do with
            the Bengali Hindus. Interestingly nothing happened in West Pakistan, the neighbour of Kashmir, probably
            because there were not enough Hindus to be killed. The blame is generally heaped on Biharis Muslims.
            However in 1990 and 1992 when Babri Mosque issue took place in Ayodhya, 1500 kilometers away from
            Dhaka, again there was mass rioting against Hindus in Bangladesh. This time there were no Bihari Muslims to
            be blamed.
            16 Tathagato Roy, My People Uprooted – pp 227, Ratna Prakashan, Calcutta, 2001.
            17 R. J. Rummel, Irving Louis Horowitz, Death by Government, pp 323, Transaction Publishers, 1997
            Presented at National Seminar on 'Migration and Its Impact on Indian State and Democracy' – 13 March 2009,
            Dept of Politics & Public Administration – University of Pune
            Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees – Idea of West Bengal at Stake – Mohit Ray 5
            government record. Out of the refugees in camps 92.7% were Hindus.18 It can be assumed
            that the refugees on their own will be mostly Hindus taking shelter in their relatives homes.
            This makes the total number of Hindu refugees as 9176627. Now Bangladesh census of
            1974 shows the number of Hindus as 967300. This means nearly all the Hindu population of
            East Pakistan took refuge in India. This shows who were the real target of Pakistan Army
            and its Bengali Muslim collaborators.
            However Bangladesh war only brought some nostalgic emotions about their lost East Bengal
            to upper caste Hindu refugees who were then mostly getting settled in West Bengal. This
            horrible aggression on their own brothers and sisters and their brutal killings evoked no
            angry response in West Bengal. The West Bengal was getting ready for new types of
            migration – Illegal migration and Undeclared refugees.
            II
            Indifferent Community, Invitation to Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees:
            Barrier to critical research
            Stunned eerie silence
            The left influence on the Bengali Hindu mind was always strong. It has attracted Bengali
            youth from the days of the IPTA (Indian People's Theatre Association). By 60's the West
            Bengal intellectual world was totally overwhelmed by leftist ideas. The '68 student rebellion
            in France, Vietnam War and Cold war between United States and Soviet Union, made the
            socialist liberation a dream for the youth in the world. Communist Party of India's
            prominence (much due to refugee power), the revolutionary zeal of Naxalite movement and
            the support of the writers, academics, film directors, musicians to all these political
            movements – all practically turned West Bengal in a leftist state without the state power.
            After so much upheaval in a society in such a small period, there is nearly no books, films or
            literature on this subject of forced migration of such a large number of people. There have
            been only stories and films made on the misery of refugee lives but never mentioning who
            made them refugees. Celebrated film maker Ritwik Ghatak's films are its best examples. Its
            not the refugees have forgotten their past, rather they flaunt their link with East Bengal
            ceremoniously. There is a famous football club named 'East Bengal' which is religiously
            supported by the refugee youth and old. There are many societies named after different
            former districts of East Bengal e.g Chattagram Sammilani (Chittagong Association),
            Mymensingh Sammilani etc. They organise different programmes but never never they
            would touch upon any subject related with happenings in East Pakistan or today's
            Bangladesh. You may go to any refugee organisation's meeting, hear fiery lectures about the
            government's apathy about the refugees' demands but never any discussion about their past
            or the present situation of their own brothers and sisters in Bangladesh. Tathagata Roy sums
            it up nicely as:
            'In such circumstances one would expect the exodus of Hindus from East Bengal to
            be a hot issue in the state of West Bengal. One would expect hundreds of books to be
            written on the subject, articles appearing in the newspapers every now and then,
            research being conducted on the political, sociological and economic reasons for the
            exodus, as well as the fallout in these fields, debates on the question ……
            18 Refugees from Bangladesh: Facts of the Refugee Problem, Bangladesh Documents, Ministry of ExternalAffairs,
            Government of India, Printed at B.N.K. Press, Madras (Chennai), 1971, pg.81 & 446.Quoted in Illegal Immigration
            From Bangladesh To India: The Emerging Conflicts, Chandan Nandy , Brandeis University, 2005
            Presented at National Seminar on 'Migration and Its Impact on Indian State and Democracy' – 13 March 2009,
            Dept of Politics & Public Administration – University of Pune
            Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees – Idea of West Bengal at Stake – Mohit Ray 6
            Indeed one is greeted with a stunned, eerie silence. The subject is never discussed
            inn polite society, never debated, never written about. If it ever comes up in the
            course of a discussion, people squirm uncomfortably until the subject is changed,
            almost in the same manner as they would in a case of incest in the family. Books on
            the subject are rarer than dinosaur's eggs, and few that are there have largely gone
            out of print.' 19
            No news from Bangladesh is good news
            Trend is same today. Average Bengali has no idea about the situation in Bangladesh or
            about the undeclared refugees. So when Bangladesh changes its secular constitution adopted
            in 1972 after liberation war in 1977, (known as 5th Amendment) to include "Absolute trust
            and faith in Allah as guiding principle of all state activities" in Fundamental Principles
            Clause 8 (1) and removes the whole Clause 12 on Secularism, it is no news in West Bengal.
            Then in 1988, Bangladesh constitution was amended (known as 8th Amendment) to declare
            Islam as state religion. In 1990 after an attack on Babri Mosque (it was not demolished then,
            just hundreds of people climbed it), a countrywide rioting took place in Bangladesh. The
            Bengali Muslims not only damaged hundreds of temples throughout the country, looted
            Hindu shops and houses, also famous temples like Dhakeswari Temple in Dhaka,
            Kaibalyadaham in Chittahong were damaged and ransacked.20 The pogrom of larger scale
            took place in 1992 after Babri Mosque was destroyed. 28000 houses, 3600 religious places
            and 2500 commercial establishments were destroyed. 13 people were killed.21 None of these
            news ever reached the West Bengal people. The newspapers observe a self-censor about the
            Islamic violence. Even the killing of Humayun Azad or assault on Shahriar Kabir did not
            find any mention in the West Bengal media. A study by BRAC Researcher summed up the
            situation as 'violence against minority was in the process being institutionalized in
            Bangladesh'. 22
            Average Bengali newspaper reader and now TV viewers have no source to know about these
            incidents. After the election of BNP-Jamat coalition under Begum Zia in October 2001 a
            massive onslaught came down on the Hindu community. Several lakhs of people fled to
            India. Hundreds of women were raped days after days. The atrocities on the Hindus
            continued for next three years. Ekattarer Ghatak Dalal Nirmul Committee (Committee for
            Resisting Killers and Collaborators of 1971) have published a three volume report on it
            edited by eminent human rights activists Shahriar Kabir.23 A case has been filed in The
            Supreme Court Of Bangladesh in 2006.24 These were never any news about such on going
            ghastly incidents in West Bengal though thousands entered West Bengal to take refuge. A
            10000 strong procession by those refugees in Kolkata and demonstration in front of
            Bangladesh Deputy High Commission in Kolkata made no news in print or electronic
            media. No human rights organizations ever even gave a press statement on the issue.
            19 Tathagato Roy, My People Uprooted – pp 292, Ratna Prakashan, Calcutta, 2001.
            20 Bangladesh Hindu Buddhist Christian Unity Council – Communal Discrimination in Bangladesh: Facts and
            Documents, pp 431-435, Dhaka 1993.
            21 Ibid pp 479-482
            22 Mohammad Rafi, Can We Get Along, pp 201, Panjere Publications, Dhaka 2005
            23 Ekattarer Ghatak Dalal Nirmul Committee – White Paper: 1500 days of Minority Persecution in Bangladesh
            – 3 Volumes, Dhaka 2005
            24 In The Supreme Court Of Bangladesh High Court Division, (Special Original Jurisdicion), Writ Petiton No.
            3380 Of 2006 BY Human Rights Congress for Bangladesh Minorities (HRCBM), Bangladesh Chapter,
            Represented by its President, Advocate Rabindra Ghosh and Human Rights And Peace For Bangladesh
            (HRPB) Represented by it's President of the Executive Committee, by Manzill Murshid – For details see Cry
            for Justice – Campaign Against Atrocities on Minorities of Bangladesh (CAAMB), Kolkata, 2006.
            Presented at National Seminar on 'Migration and Its Impact on Indian State and Democracy' – 13 March 2009,
            Dept of Politics & Public Administration – University of Pune
            Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees – Idea of West Bengal at Stake – Mohit Ray 7
            Migration Research: Questionable 'Objectivity'
            In this mindset any research on the subject of Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees
            which no doubt would involve the Muslims and Bangladesh is a taboo in West Bengal.
            When even eminent historians like Amalendu De, an expert in Islamic History and ex-
            President of The Asiatic Society writes on infiltration, he finds no publisher and had to do
            with unknown little publisher.25 Similarly Prafulla Chakraborty, well known for his books
            on European History, could not find publisher for his seminal work 'The Marginal Men' and
            had to print himself. The most striking aspects of this source book published in 1990 that it
            has a very brief bibliography – simply because there is hardly any work on this issue. In last
            decade there has been some work on the issue of migration and refugees due to international
            funding on this subject. But still the researchers are very careful not to cross the sacred line
            what is known as 'secularism'.
            Chandan Nandy, the author of one of the few extensively researched treatises on the subject.
            States:
            'I had to approach the field research with extreme caution lest I ended up "taking
            sides", especially because the pernicious debate between the left, centre and right of
            the Indian political spectrum invariably casts researchers as either "communal" or
            "secular"..'26.
            It is difficult to survive in academic field and also get research funding if you are once
            branded as 'communal', especially in Left-run West Bengal. A detailed study of transborder
            migration from Bangladesh to West Bengal by Ranabir Samaddar provides human stories,
            theories, some useful data but very careful not to put any attention on the communal nature
            of Bangladesh. But such a massive reality could not be hidden so he provided a generous
            subsection 'The vanishing Hindus of Bangladesh' in which only Vested Property Act has
            been shown as the reason for such vanishing trick.27 Enough literature on the worst riots of
            1990, and 1992, the rapes of hundreds of women of Bhola and others were easily available,
            but you cannot survive in the academic field if you mention those unmentionable which
            would drag the issue of Islamic violence. So Sammadar was much annoyed when a BSF
            hindi-speaking jawan reminded him to read 'Lajja',28 to understand the illegal migration.
            Samaddar was not happy that BSF jawan besides guarding the border should also know
            about Lajja and its impact.29. Of course for Samaddar, these riots or vanishing Hindus is a
            normal historical process which he welcomes as he writes in the introduction of his book,
            'My argument here is that though the human flows are very much a part and product
            of globalization, they also indicate a return to history, to local history and a past
            narrative of community, in short, they signal continuity. 30
            And
            'Here I argue that the nation as a configuration is being continuously redefined, not
            the least through forces such as population flow……31
            25 Amalendu De – Prasanga Anuprabesh (On Infiltration) – Barna Parichay, Kolkata, 1993.
            26 Chandan Nandy, Illegal Immigration From Bangladesh To India: The Emerging Conflicts, pp XV, Brandeis
            University, 2005
            27 Ranabir Samaddar, The Marginal Nation, pp 92-94, Sage Publications, Delhi, 1999.
            28 Lajja is a novel in Bengali by Taslima Nasrin which for the first time depicted brutal torture on Hindus
            during the riot inn Bangladesh. She has been banished from Bangladesh and then also banished from West
            Bengal by the rioting Muslim mob, the demand supported by all the major political parties in West Bengal e,g
            CPI-M, Trinamul Congress and Congress. The 'civil society' also remained a mute spectator
            29 Ranabir Samaddar, The Marginal Nation, pp 11-112, Sage Publications, Delhi, 1999.
            30 Ibid pp 21
            31 Ibid pp 13
            Presented at National Seminar on 'Migration and Its Impact on Indian State and Democracy' – 13 March 2009,
            Dept of Politics & Public Administration – University of Pune
            Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees – Idea of West Bengal at Stake – Mohit Ray 8
            So Mr Samaddar is waiting to see formation of a new nation in West Bengal, we shall see
            later what the face of that new 'neo nation' would be.
            On a similar line a paper from Indian Statistical Institute on 'undocumented migration' the
            researcher tries to avoid the religious issue in a peculiar manner. She writes that 'It is to be
            borne in mind that Bangladesh is not a secular state. Religion does play a role in migration'
            but then goes on to say about the political and economic causes only responsible for four
            phases of migration from Bangladesh.32. The paper mentioning religious issue in several
            parts of the article had identified the Five 'Push Factors' in Bangladesh to be Economic,
            Demographic, Social, Political and Law and Order.33 She covers up religion under the wrap
            of 'law and order'. Reacting to this article another academic comments,
            Migration from Bangladesh to West Bengal has been a continuous process since
            1947. The reasons are historical, political, social, cultural, economic, geographical
            and environmental.34
            Note the list of factors for migration again, citing everything except religious or communal
            factors.
            III
            Needed: Differentially Defining Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees
            Definitions
            Let us first clarify the terms 'Illegal migration', 'Undeclared Refugees' and 'Infiltrators'.
            There have been many discussions on the issue of migration and its legality including the
            unfettered right of migration of people. Any such theoretical debate is avoided here. It is
            simply that whoever enters a country without proper legal papers or reside without legal
            permission after entering legally is an 'illegal migrant'. There should be no ambiguity in
            that. How that illegal migrant has to be treated is a different issue altogether.
            A Refuggee is defined in Article 1 of the 1951 UN Convention as amended by the 1967
            Protocol as:
            "A person who owing to a well-founded fear of being persecuted for reasons of race,
            religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion, is
            outside the country of his nationality and is unable or, owing to such fear, is
            unwilling to avail himself of the protection of that country; or who, not having a
            nationality and being outside the country of his former habitual residence as a result
            of such events, is unable or, owing to such fear, is unwilling to return to it.."
            However India, Pakistan, Bangladesh are not signatories to this convention or protocol. So
            by international law there have never been any refugees in between these countries. The
            2005 UN data shows that in India there are 77200 refugees from China, 50730 from Sri
            Lanka, 9700 from Afghanistan, 1471 from Myanmar and 104 from Somalia. So UN keeps
            no data on the refugees of the subcontinent. Recently on 19 June 2007, a minority rights
            group Human Rights Congress for Bangladesh Minorities has filed a writ petition at
            Calcutta High Court on June 19th, 2007 appealing that Government of India should grant
            32 Pranati Datta, Push-Pull Factors of Undocumented Migration from Bangladesh to West Bengal: A
            Perception Study The Qualitative Report pp 348-349, Volume 9 Number 2 June 2004 338-339
            33 Ibid pp 348-350
            34 Refugee Watch Issue No. 18, April 2003
            Presented at National Seminar on 'Migration and Its Impact on Indian State and Democracy' – 13 March 2009,
            Dept of Politics & Public Administration – University of Pune
            Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees – Idea of West Bengal at Stake – Mohit Ray 9
            Refugee status to Bangladesh Minorities, who took shelter in India to escape violence in
            their country.35
            So the term refugee is considered here following the definition UN convention though India
            or Bangladesh is not a signatory. By that definition the Hindus from Bangladesh are entitled
            to be considered as 'Refugee'. Till 25 March 1971, the Hindus who crossed over to India
            from East Pakistan were issued a receipt of their entry into the country. This receipt or slip
            was the proof of their 'refugee' status and they were subsequently granted citizenship of the
            country. These people are considered as legal refugees. Even Government of India's notes
            also refer them as 'refugees'.
            On 29 November 1971, Government of India through its Under Secretary C.L.Goyal issued
            an Express letter No. 26011/16/71-10 to the Chief Secretaries to all State Governments and
            Union Territories Administrations. Its Subject: Grant of Indian Citizenship to refugees from
            East Bengal who have crossed over to India after 25th March 1971. Instruction that
            application from such refugees for Indian Citizenship should not be entertained.36
            According to the Sec 5.1(a) of Citizenship Act 1955, persons of Indian origin who are
            ordinarily resident in India and have been resident for five years immediately before making
            an application for registration; 37. The refugees from East Pakistan naturally became Indian
            citizens afterwards.
            The situation changed from 26th March, 1971, the category of 'Undeclared Refugees' came
            into being.
            So the 'illegal migrants' other than 'the undeclared refugees' can be termed as 'infiltrators'.
            By this definition infiltrator is a Bangladeshi Muslim as others like Hindus, Christians,
            Buddhists or Ahmedias can claim the status of a refugee due to religious persecution.
            Citizenship Act 2003 and Undeclared Refugees
            Though the provision of obtaining citizenship for these undeclared refugees were stopped by
            a notice, it was thought to be a temporary affair as there was still no legal bar from obtaining
            the citizenship. The act has been amended seven times. Till 1986 anyone born in India had
            the right to be an Indian citizen. Sons and daughters of the 'undeclared refugees' could
            therefore be Indian citizen. After 1986, only son or daughter of an Indian citizen can be a
            citizen. So the refugees who entered after 1986, not only they but their future sons and
            daughters are to be all illegal migrants.
            The scenario changed further after the passing of Citizenship Act 2003 by Bharatiya Janata
            Party (BJP)-led NDA Government. The act aimed to please NRI Indians by providing them
            a chance of dual citizenship, but in the process, this party preaching Hinduttwa caused a
            major harm to the Hindu Refugees from Bangladesh coming after 25 March 1971. It further
            restricted the chance of getting citizenship for this undeclared refugees by stating that if the
            father or mother is an illegal migrant, their son or daughter is also illegal migrant. So several
            millions of undeclared refugees from Bangladesh have lost all hopes of citizenship
            What was the reaction for such a devastating act and that too done by 'communal' NDA? At
            the intervention of the state of Gujarat and Rajasthan, citizenship have been given to the
            36 Debojyoti Roy – Keno Udbastu Hote Holo (Why we had to become refugees) – pp 175, Vivekananda
            Sahitya Kendra, Kolkata 2001.
            37 See Citizenship Act, 1955
            Presented at National Seminar on 'Migration and Its Impact on Indian State and Democracy' – 13 March 2009,
            Dept of Politics & Public Administration – University of Pune
            Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees – Idea of West Bengal at Stake – Mohit Ray 10
            several thousands Hindus displaced from Sindh residing in those states following the
            guidelines of section 18 of the Act and subsequent rules of 2004.
            But West Bengal remained silent. The Act which has been passed for 5 years but till now no
            worthwhile discussion on this life and death issue of millions of undeclared refugees have
            appeared neither in print media or electronic media. Hundreds of Bengali 'little magazines',
            considered to be heart of Bengali intellectualism, which brings out special issues on
            'Palestine' to 'HIV Aids', never touched such an important issue.
            IV
            The Numbers: Demographic Disaster in West Bengal and Ethnic Cleansing in
            Bangladesh.
            Demographical Disaster
            Let us start with some of the most easily available statistics of change of Hindu and Muslim
            population in Bangladesh and West Bengal. Tables of growth of Hindu and Muslim
            population in Bangladesh and West Bengal are provided in details below:
            Table 1
            Hindu and Muslim Population Growth in West Bengal & Bangladesh, 1951-2001
            1951 1961 1974
            Religions Total
            Population
            (%)
            Total
            Population
            (%)
            Growth
            Rate (%)
            1951-61
            Total
            Population
            (%)
            Growth
            Rate (%)
            1961-74
            Bangladesh All Religions 41933 50840 21.24 71478 40.59
            Hindus 9239 (22.0) 9380 (18.5) 1.53 9673 (13.5) 3.12
            Muslims 32227 (76.9) 40890 (80.4) 26.88 61039 (85.4) 49.28
            1981 1991 2001
            Religions Total
            Population
            (%)
            Growth
            Rate
            (%)
            1974-81
            Total
            Population
            (%)
            Growth
            Rate
            (%)
            1981-91
            Total
            Population
            (%)
            Growth
            Rate
            (%)
            1991-01
            Growth
            Rate
            (%)
            1951-
            2001
            Bangladesh All
            Religions
            87120 21.88 106315 22.03 123851 16.49 195.35
            Hindus 10570
            (12.1)
            9.27 11179
            (10.5)
            5.76 11379
            (9.2)
            1.79 23.16
            Muslims 74587
            (86.7)
            22.20 93881
            (88.3)
            25.87 111079
            (89.7)
            18.32 244.68
            1951 1961 1971
            Religions Total Population
            (%)
            Total
            Population
            (%)
            Growth Rate
            (%) 1951-61
            Total
            Population
            (%)
            Growth Rate
            (%) 1961-71
            West
            Bengal
            All
            Religions
            24810308 34926279 32.80 44312011 26.87
            Hindus 19462706
            (78.45)
            27523358
            (78.80)
            41.42 34611864
            (78.11)
            25.75
            Muslims 4925496 (19.85) 6985287
            (20.00)
            41.82 9064338
            (20.46)
            29.76
            1981 1991 2001
            Religions Total
            Population
            (%)
            Growth
            Rate (%)
            1971-81
            Total
            Population
            (%)
            Growth
            Rate (%)
            1981-91
            Total
            Population
            (%)
            Growth
            Rate (%)
            1991-01
            Growth
            Rate (%)
            1951-
            Presented at National Seminar on 'Migration and Its Impact on Indian State and Democracy' – 13 March 2009,
            Dept of Politics & Public Administration – University of Pune
            Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees – Idea of West Bengal at Stake – Mohit Ray 11
            2001
            West
            Bengal
            All
            Religions
            54580647 23.17 68077965 24.73 80176197 17.84 223.16
            Hindus 42007159
            (76.96)
            21.37 50866624
            (74.72)
            21.09 58104835
            (72.47)
            14.23 198.54
            Muslims 11743259
            (21.51)
            29.55 16075836
            (23.61)
            36.89 20240543
            (25.25)
            25.91 310.13
            Table 2
            Districtwise Demographic Change In West Bengal 1951-2001
            Population Ratio in Percent (%)
            Region 1951 2001 % Change
            West Bengal Hindu 78.45 72.47 -5.98
            Muslim 19.85 25.25 +5.4
            Darjiling Hindu 81.71 76.92 -4.79
            Muslim 1.14 5.31 +4.17
            Jalpaiguri Hindu 84.18 83.3 -0.88
            Muslim 9.74 10.85 +1.11
            Kochbihar Hindu 70.90 75.50 +4.6
            Muslim 28.94 24.24 -4.7
            Uttar & Dakshin Dinajpur Hindu 69.30 60.22 -9.08
            Muslim 29.94 38.47 +8.53
            Maldah Hindu 62.92 49.28 -13.64
            Muslim 36.97 49.72 +12.75
            Murshidabad Hindu 44.60 35.92 -8.68
            Muslim 55.24 63.67 +8.43
            Birbhum Hindu 72.60 64.69 -7.91
            Muslim 26.86 35.08 +8.22
            Bardhaman Hindu 83.73 78.89 -4.84
            Muslim 15.60 19.78 +4.18
            Nadia Hindu 77.03 73.75 -3.28
            Muslim 22.36 25.41 +3.05
            North 24 Pgs* Hindu 77.26
            (1971)
            75.23 -2.03
            Muslim 22.43
            (1971)
            24.22 +1.79
            South 24 Pgs* Hindu 72.96
            (1971)
            65.86 -7.1
            Muslim 26.05
            (1971)
            33.24 +7.19
            Hugli Hindu 86.52 83.63 -2.89
            Muslim 13.27 15.14 +1.87
            Bankura Hindu 91.16 84.35 -6.81
            Muslim 4.40 7.51 +3.11
            Puruliya* Hindu 93.13
            (1961)
            83.42 -9.71
            Muslim 5.99 (1961) 7.12 +1.13
            Medinipur Hindu 91.78 85.58 -6.2
            Muslim 7.17 11.33 +4.16
            Haora Hindu 83.45 74.98 -8.47
            Muslim 16.22 24.44 +8.22
            Kolkata Hindu 83.41 77.68 -5.73
            Muslim 12.00 20.27 +8.27
            Source: Census of India, 2001
            * Adjusted Data
            # Exept Kochbihar, all districts had increase in Muslim Population
            Presented at National Seminar on 'Migration and Its Impact on Indian State and Democracy' – 13 March 2009,
            Dept of Politics & Public Administration – University of Pune
            Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees – Idea of West Bengal at Stake – Mohit Ray 12
            # Maldah , a Hindu majority district has been turned into Muslim majority
            # South Dinajpur district is on the verge of turning into Muslim majority
            # Border districts of Maldah, Murshidabad, Uttar & Dakhsin Dinajpur, South 24 Parganas and Kolkata &
            Howrah have high increase.
            Let us look the data carefully. Remember what Shyamaprasad Mukherjee told in 1950 while
            resigining from Nehru's cabinet. The unusual growth of Muslim population during 1951-61
            bears out his warnings. While Hindu population growth is very high of 41.42% due to huge
            influx of Hindu refugees from East Pakistan38, Muslim population growth was higher at
            41.82%. No natural growth can explain this except massive coming back of Muslims back to
            West Bengal. Remember the role of UCRC, demanding rehabilitation of the Muslims and
            criticizing Shyamaprasad. Though the Hindu refugee influx continued39, the Muslim growth
            rate still surpassed that. It is a puzzle nobody bothered to look into. The worst demographic
            disaster happened during the height of rule of Jyoti Basu, the CPIM's and country's longest
            serving chief minister. West Bengal's population growth rate was higher than the Indian
            national average till 1971 due to high influx of refugees. During 1971-81, for the first time
            West Bengal population growth rate went below the national average. During 1981-1991
            again West Bengal population growth rate became above national average. During that
            period Hindu growth rate decreased from previous decade (you must keep in mind that
            influx of Hindu refugees never stopped), the Muslim growth was a phenomenal 36.89%. If
            there were any normal atmosphere of research and study in West Bengal, this abnormal
            population scenario should have been a major issue of debate, academic study, election
            issue, planning, environment etc. However it was silence as ever. Only a respected historian
            like Professor Amalendu De, once a member of Communist Party who married into the
            family of Fazlul Haq, the legendary leader Bengali Muslim peasantry, braved to write a
            small book on infiltration which was criticized in CPI(M)'s daily.40
            In 1991-2001 the growth rate reduced but still had a large gap with the growth rate of Hindu
            population. So from 19.85% in 1951, Muslim population in West Bengal shot up to 25.85%
            in 2001. Remember Ambedkar's visionary comment on numbers, this became the reality
            after 50 years of creation of the state of West Bengal.
            Compare the overall growth rate in 50 years in two parts. In West Bengal, Hindu population
            growth rate was 198.54%, Muslim growth rate was one and half times higher at 310.13%! In
            Bangladesh, Hindu population growth rate was 23.16%, while Muslim population growth
            rate was more than ten times, at 244.68%. A comparative study of the population and the
            growth details of these two countries can be found in Bimal Praminik's well-researched
            book.41
            Worst Ethnic Cleansing in Peace Times
            One can have a comparative look at the situation in Bangladesh. It can only be called 'the
            worst ethnic cleansing in recent history'. We have mentioned before the 'gentle push' and
            'violent riots' as the reasons for Hindu exodus. The other major reason was the 'Enemy
            Property Act, 1965' which was in fact an evolution of different earlier acts to grab the
            38 Amalendu De pp 3-4
            39 Ibid pp 5-7
            40 Ibid
            41 Bimal Pramanik, Endangered Demography – Nature and Impact of Demographic Changes in West Bengal
            1951-2001 Kolkata 2005. The updated Bengali version is named – Paschimbange AshaniSanket.
            Presented at National Seminar on 'Migration and Its Impact on Indian State and Democracy' – 13 March 2009,
            Dept of Politics & Public Administration – University of Pune
            Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees – Idea of West Bengal at Stake – Mohit Ray 13
            properties of the Hindus.42 The Enemy Property Act of Pakistan was renamed as Vested
            Property Act after the emergence of Bangladesh. Abul Barkat, Professor of Economics in
            Dhaka University, has done seminal work on this subject. Even after the Pakistan regime is
            gone, Vested Property Act is still used to grab Hindu properties, an interesting example is
            given by Prof Barkat in the preface of his book:
            The tales of prominent persons who have been affected by the VPA are well known.
            For example, Mr. Dhirendra Nath Dutta, the veteran politician from Comilla,
            freedom fighter against the British Raj, and a member of the then-Pakistan
            Constituent Assembly, raised the first voice of protest in the Parliament against
            imposition of Urdu as the only state language of Pakistan and demanded Bangla be
            recognized as a State Language. After dedicating his whole life to the people and
            fighting to his last breath for the cause of the country, Shaheed Dhirendra Nath
            Dutta was brutally tortured and killed along with his son Dilip Dutta by Pakistani
            Armies in 1971 in Comilla Cantonment. The tiny, token village property left to his
            family after he had donated the rest of his landed property for welfare and
            educational purposes in his village Ramrail in Brahmanbaria District was grabbed
            by a group of people under the pretext of 'vested property.' In response to the case
            filed by his family members in the Subjudge Court of Brahmanbaria, the Court
            demanded that the family produce Shaheed Dhirendra Nath Dutta's death
            certificate, an impossibility in the case of a liberation was martyr, Other eminent
            personalities such as Masterda Surjya Sen, who dedicated his life to the freedom
            struggle against the British Raj, Mr. Amal Sen, a veteran leader of peasant
            movement in British India who because of his involvement in the political struggle
            for freedom and democracy spent about twenty years in Pakistani prison, and Mr.
            Barin Mazumder, the renowned classical artist who devoted his life to developing
            the music and culture of this country, had their properties listed as enemy properties
            by the Pakistani administration.43
            In his later work, he estimated about 6.3 million missing Hindu population during 1971-
            1991. These are our undeclared refugees. If two third of these people settle in West Bengal,
            the number of undeclared refugees will be 4.2 million. Let us see in details about Prof
            Barkat's estimation:
            'According to the 2001 Bangladesh Population Census, the total size of the Hindu
            population in Bangladesh was 11.4 million. Assuming the 1961 population share of
            the Hindu population (18.4%), the absolute size of the Hindu population in 2001
            would have been 22.8 million instead of 11.4 million as reported in the census, i.e.,
            the actual current (2001) size is half (50%) of the expected size, Mass out-migration
            of Hindu population (mostly of India) during mid-1960s and onward is a reality
            beyond doubt. Among the various factors responsible for such out-migrations of the
            Hindu population, the effects of the Enemy / Vested Property Act were important
            ones. The exact effect of all these factors (e.g., communal riots, Indo-Pak War of
            1965, Enemy and Vested Property Acts) is difficult to quantify due to lack of relevant
            reliable information. Thus, an attempt has been made to estimate the mission Hindu
            population during 1964-1971, 1971-1981, 1981-1991, and 1991-2001 using
            appropriate assumptions.
            According to the information in the Population Census, the average annual
            growth rates of the Muslim Population was 3.13 percent for 1961-1974, 3.08 percent
            for 1974-1981, 2.20 percent for 1981-1991, and 1.7 percent for 1991-2001 periods.
            42 Abul Barkat et al – Political Economy of Vested Property Act in Rural Bangladesh, pp 19-44. Association
            for Land Reform and Development, Dhaka, 1997.
            43 Ibid pp xi-xii.
            Presented at National Seminar on 'Migration and Its Impact on Indian State and Democracy' – 13 March 2009,
            Dept of Politics & Public Administration – University of Pune
            Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees – Idea of West Bengal at Stake – Mohit Ray 14
            Assuming a 13 percent lower fertility rates for the Hindus compared to the Muslims,
            the average annual growth rates of Hindu population in "no out-migration"
            situation would have been 2.72 percent during 1964-1971, 2.68 percent during
            1971-1981, 1.92 percent during 1981-1991, and 1.48 percent during 1991-2001.
            By extrapolating the above rates, the Hindu population in 1971 would have
            been 11.4 million instead of 9.6 million as reported in the official documents. The
            Hindu population would have been 14.3 million in 1981 instead of 10.6 million, 16.5
            million in 1991 instead of 11.2 million, and 19.5 million in 2001 instead of 11.4
            million. Therefore, there were some 1.8 million mission Hindu population during
            1964-1971, 1.9 million missing Hindu population during 1971-1981, 1.6 million
            missing Hindu population during 1981-1991, and 2.8 million missing Hindu
            population during 1991-2001. Thus the estimated total missing Hindu population
            was 8.1 million during 1964-2001, i.e., 218,919 Hindus missing each year. In other
            words, if out-migration of the Hindu population is caused mainly by communal
            disharmony resulting from the Enemy / Vested Property Acts, the approximate size of
            the missing Hindu population would be 600 persons per day during 1964-2001. The
            approximate size of the missing Hindu population was as high as 705 persons per
            day during 1964-1971, as against 521 persons per day during 1971-1981,
            decreasing to 438 persons per day during 1981-1991, and rising to 767 persons per
            day during 1991-2001.44
            Interestingly, though these missing population have come to West Bengal, the Economics
            Departments of various Universities in West Bengal never cared to carry out research
            corresponding to what Prof Barkat has done. The reason is well known.
            Now we proceed to the numbers from the Indian side.
            Infiltrators - how many
            What is the number of infiltrators? Government sources do not segregate between the illegal
            migrants and the undeclared refugees, only sometimes some figures are given. Let us go by
            some initial government statistics and the reactions by the Congress and the Left parties.
            Home Minister Shri Indrajit Gupta in reply to a question in Parliament on 6th May, 1990
            stated that the number of illegal immigrants in India was about one crore. So by 1990, a
            figure of 10 million comes into discussion. Now see the reaction of Priya Ranjan Dasmunsi,
            an important Congress leader from West Bengal:
            Mr. Chairman, Sir, I heard in the last two occasions this particular debate on
            this resolution. Before I participate in the discussion on the resolution, I had the
            privilege to hear the distinguished Home Minister Shri Indrajit Gupta the other
            day while replying to a question. I do not know the reason and the logistics which
            provided him the strength to admit in the House that about ten million foreigners
            are now residing in India. Having said so on the floor of the House that ten million
            foreigners are in the country at the moment and also admitting the fact that the
            people who are to prevent their entry from across the border, are not performing
            their jobs very efficiently, it really gave a handle to those who have been creating a
            lot of hue and cry on this issue and to a great extent had communalised this
            campaign as Shri Banatwalla said just now.
            So mentioning the number of ten million of infiltrators irritated Mr Dasmunsi very much.
            What more to please the infiltrators waiting to enter. Mr Dasmunshi continues:
            44 Abdul Barkat et al – Deprivation of Hindu Minority in Bangladesh- Living with Vested Property, pp 66-68,
            Pathak Samabesh, Dhaka, 2008.
            Presented at National Seminar on 'Migration and Its Impact on Indian State and Democracy' – 13 March 2009,
            Dept of Politics & Public Administration – University of Pune
            Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees – Idea of West Bengal at Stake – Mohit Ray 15
            Sir, it is a fact that historically when India, Pakistan and Bangladesh were
            together during the days of freedom struggle, when we were all one against the
            British empire, our cultural, social, and political aspirations and our emotional
            ties were one. …… Be it a Muslim in Bangladesh, be it a Muslim in Pakistan,
            their dreams for this sub-continent in the days of the struggle against the British
            and their cultural, religious, emotional passion, are the same today also. ….
            Let us take stock of our border States and Provinces. Jammu, Kashmir, Punjab,
            Rajasthan and Gujarat border with Pakistan. Whether you like it or not, if
            anything goes wrong in these four States, a habit has developed in this country
            just to doubt and cast aspersions on the Muslims of this area, as
            the agents of Pakistan. ….. If there is a war again, the spies of the Government will
            start finding out whether the agents might not be anybody other than the
            Muslims. Let us try to understand in what manner we are cheating them day in
            and day out.
            Do you need a Jamat or Muslim league anymore in India while Dasmunshis are there? Mr
            Dasmunshi goes on even encouraging to violate the Indian Citizenship Act standing in
            Indian Parliament:
            Thirty years ago, a daily wage earner of the agricultural field, may be his name
            is, Shri Ramatulla Khan, could not thrive in his own part and maybe on the side of
            Tripura or West Bengal or Assam, the big landlords whether Hindu or Muslim,
            asked Shri Ramatulla Khan during agriculture season to come and work in the field
            and to give support to agricultural production. Shri Ramatulla Khan went and
            stayed there for long with his family and children. Now when the time has come
            to identify, we do not go to the background as to how Shri Ramatulla Khan came
            in. We go straight to the child and tell like this: "Look here, your father came
            here as an illegal immigrant. We have enough documents because Rahmatullah
            used to stay in a village till 16th August 1947 or till such and such a date of August
            1950 or August, 1960. You are his child and get out from here." This is the kind of
            an attitude we have always adopted throughout the country.
            A Memebr of Parliament standing inside Parliament telling the administration not to disturb
            the infiltrator family! And then Mr Dasmunsi introduces his background. –
            I was born in Bangladesh….. One night I came out and found that there was a
            trouble. My father, mother and sister were staying in the House and the house
            with all the property was lit. The next day morning, I found that the gentleman
            and his brother, who escorted us safely to cross the border, were Muslims. After
            having successfully crossed the border, myself, my mother and my sister arrived
            by train at the border of India. After seven days, we gathered the news that the great
            Muslim family which helped us had been killed at the hands of some fanatics. I still
            remember it….. When I became a Minister, I went to visit their family. What a
            contribution they have made for promoting brotherhood!
            A fantastic account from a refugee boy! The so much celebration of Hindu-Muslim
            brotherhood. But then why the Dasmunshi family came from East Pakistan and stayed back
            in India. In some incident, his family house might be burnt, they also could take shelter in
            another place for a few days but why they did not go back to his ancestral home again!!
            The issue of infiltrators also dogged the days of Shri Jyoti Basu, whose government was
            responsible for this invasion to begin. In an article published in CPI-M's Bengali daily
            Ganashakti on 11 October 1992, on the Infiltration problem Jyoti Basu wrote:
            ..From 1979 the Muslims are also coming to India. Between 1977 to 1992, BSF has
            identified and pushed back 2,35,529 Bangladeshi infiltrators. Amongst them 68472
            Presented at National Seminar on 'Migration and Its Impact on Indian State and Democracy' – 13 March 2009,
            Dept of Politics & Public Administration – University of Pune
            Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees – Idea of West Bengal at Stake – Mohit Ray 16
            were Hindus and 1,64,132 were Muslims. At the same time between 1977 to 1992,
            Mobile task Force has pushed back 2,16, 985 Bangladeshi infiltrators. Amongst
            them 56342 were Hindus and 1,69,795 are Muslims.45
            So we find during 15 years about 4.5 lakhs of infiltrators were pushed back and 73% of
            them were Muslims. If we consider that only 30% of the infiltrators are caught, then this
            itself is enough to quantify the problem of Muslim infiltration in West Bengal.
            On July 14, 2004, in reply to a question in the Parliament, the Congress Minister of State for
            Home Affairs Sri Prakash Jaiswal informed that there 1 crore 20 lakhs 53 thousand and 950
            illegal Bangladeshi in the country. Out of that West Bengal has 57 Lakhs of the illegal
            Bangladeshi. The list is given below. As usual when the pro-islamic 'secular' media raised a
            hue and cry, the minister had to say that 'the reported figures were not based on any
            comprehensive or sample study but were based on hearsay and that too from interested
            parties. Therefore, no realistic figures can be given for illegal Bangladeshi migrants in
            Assam. In the case of West Bengal also the figures are based on unreliable estimates and are
            incorrect'46 The figure also show that there are 3,75,000 Bangladeshis in Delhi and this may
            mean that there are more Bangladeshi Bengalees in National Capital than the Indian
            Bengalees. This also shows the incompetence of BJP governments who ruled both the Delhi
            State and the Central Government in recent times.
            Table 3
            Bangladeshi Migrants in India - 2004
            State Estimated Number
            Arunachal Padesh 800
            Assam 5000000
            Bihar 47900
            Gujarat 100
            Haryana 550
            Madya Pradesh 700
            Maharashtra 20400
            Meghalaya 30000
            Nagaland 59500
            Orissa 30850
            Punjab 150
            Rajasthan 2500
            Tripura 325400
            UP 26000
            W Bengal 5700000
            Andaman & Nikobar 3000
            Delhi 375000
            11622850
            45 Quoted in Prasanga Anuprabesh – Amalendu De, pp 125-26. Barna Parichay, Kolkata 1993.
            46 Chandan Nandy, Illegal Immigration From Bangladesh To India: The Emerging Conflicts, pp 132-34,
            Brandeis University, 2005
            Presented at National Seminar on 'Migration and Its Impact on Indian State and Democracy' – 13 March 2009,
            Dept of Politics & Public Administration – University of Pune
            Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees – Idea of West Bengal at Stake – Mohit Ray 17
            Chandan Nandy has done excellent work by tracking the infiltrators and their modous
            operandi, both in West Bengal and Assam, by direct field study and from secondary
            sources.47 He provides one nice example:
            The fact that West Bengal has been and continues to be a favourite destination for
            Bangladeshi migrants is testified by the results of a pilot project that the Government
            of India launched in 2003 in the Murshidabad-Jiaganj belt of Muslim-majority
            Murshidabad district, believed to be home to hundreds of thousands of Bangladeshi
            migrants, as part of its larger scheme to issue multi-purpose national identity cards
            to citizens. The work on the ground was to be executed by the district administration.
            The Murshidabad-Jiaganj belt was chosen along with a few other areas in some of
            the border states of India as a feasibility project whose objective was "quick
            identification and deportation of illegal migrants in the country as also a credible
            identification system for multifarious socioeconomic use…that would involve a
            massive exercise of compulsory registration of all citizens and non-citizens".
            Although the final report is yet to be submitted to the government, the provisional
            findings of the Murshidabad-Jiaganj project came up with startling results: Of the
            255,000 people covered under the project, only 9.4 per cent or 24,000, could
            produce "at least one supporting document" of their Indian nationality; 90.6 per
            cent or 231,000 could not produce even one of the 19 prescribed documents. The
            newspaper that broke the story had this to say: At first glance, the revelation seems
            to confirm what critics of the Left Front government have been alleging – that the
            state machinery has papered over the existence of a huge mass of populace which
            does not belong to the country but has been allowed to stay on as captive vote
            bank.48 Those who could not produce any of the prescribed documents – land deeds,
            ration card, drivers' licence, voters' identity card to name a few – have been put
            under the category of "citizenship in suspense". One junior bureaucrat said that
            over the years, Lalgola
            The reaction of the CPI-M was, not surprisingly, similar: "It is a sensitive issue and
            not possible for the state alone to combat it…But your figures are absurd."49….
            Neither the West Bengal government nor the CPI-M agrees that the estimated
            number of Bangladeshi illegal immigrants in the state is 'no fewer than 10 million'.
            So the unprecedented scale of the infiltration and undeclared refugee influx is a case in
            point, though it never received an iota of legitimate attention.
            V
            Impact: Secular Democratic Society At Stake
            Though we do not know the exact figure of either the infiltration or undeclared refugee
            influx but the scale is clearly perceptible. Abul Barkat's estimates provide 4.5 million
            undeclared refugees. Some of them have come with regular visas but mostly without any
            documents. We find from previous discussions that the Muslim infiltrators are nearly three
            times the Hindu refugees trying to sneak in to India. Taking that figure, the number of
            47 Ibid, pp 125-147,
            48 Purohit, Devdeep, Bengal's Masses Without an Identity, The Telegraph, Calcutta, August 11, 2005,
            49 Biswas, Anil, West Bengal CPI-M Secretary and Politburo Member, Quoted in Our Bureau, Government,
            Party Shed Influx Blinkers, The Telegraph, Calcutta, August 12, 2005.
            Presented at National Seminar on 'Migration and Its Impact on Indian State and Democracy' – 13 March 2009,
            Dept of Politics & Public Administration – University of Pune
            Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees – Idea of West Bengal at Stake – Mohit Ray 18
            infiltrators will be around 12 to 14 million. We have an illegal population of say 15-18
            millions of which many are not recorded in any registrar. So West Bengal's real population
            may be between 80 to 90 million, not 80 million recorded in Census 2001. But as the
            numbers are not specific, the impact can be predicted only qualitatively.
            The impact of an unrecorded population of such a magnitude cannot be ignored at social,
            economic, political or environmental level. Let us first take the issue of any planning for the
            state which include Food, Shelter, Sanitation, Education – the basic needs. West Bengal is
            already one of the most underperforming states. NSS 61st Round, July 2004-June 2005
            showed that the percentage of rural household not getting enough food every day in some
            months of the year was the highest in West Bengal (10.6 per cent). 50 So when you have a
            large number of unrecorded people it is diffcult to plan. From environmental point of view,
            West Bengal already is the most densely populated state in the country. It is impossible to
            take more people in it. We have already seen that land is such a scarce resource in West
            Bengal, it has become the focal point of all development issues. Already the issue of land in
            Singur and Nandigram villages have caused a political turmoil in the state which has further
            economic impact in terms future investment of industrial capital in West Bengal. So if these
            influx of infiltrators and undeclared refugees continues unabetted, the problem will intensify
            in the coming days.
            The alarming increse of population put excess pressure on the natural resources. More the
            people are poor, more they depend on direct natural resources for livelihood. It can be water
            from the ponds, wood from the jungle or other house building materials. All these have
            direct impact on environment and public health. The undeclared refugees living along the
            train tracks connecting Kolkata to the eastern border town of Bangaon are already creating a
            havoc on environment and public health. The infiltrators residing on the border villages or
            working in the towns also face similar problems due to poverty. A poor state like West
            Bengal is often helpless in the face of such influx.
            Planning with a large dose of finacial help can mitigate the economic problems to some
            acceptable level, but the cultural, political and social environmental impacts are often
            irreversible.
            Expansion of Madrasas and Assault on Secualr Education
            After coming to power in 1978, Left-front government went full steam ahead to encourage
            madrasa education. Their yearly list of successes always include the success of spreading
            more madrasa education with ever-larger state funding. While students of various other
            religions study under different non-religious educational boards (West Bengal Board of
            Secondary Education, Central Board of Secondary Education, Indian School Certificate
            Examination etc), the Muslims have to study under a Islamic educational board, the
            rationale is never questioned. This is not a place of detailed discussion on it but these
            madrasas are the cradles of Islamic fundamentalism. This was publicly admitted by Shri
            Buddhadeb Bhattacharya, the Communist Chief Minister of West Bengal, while
            commenting on attacks on US Centre in Kolkata in January 2002. Of course later he had to
            eat his own words, saying he was misquoted.51
            Again remember the number game mentioned by B R Ambedkar. As the number of
            Muslims without any progressive leadership increases, there is always an ever-expanding
            space for bargain for orthodoxy. Now all the political parties from CPI-M led Left Front to
            50 D. Bandyopadhyay, On Poverty, Food Inadequacy and Hunger in West Bengal, 19 June 2007 Mainstream
            4439.html
            Presented at National Seminar on 'Migration and Its Impact on Indian State and Democracy' – 13 March 2009,
            Dept of Politics & Public Administration – University of Pune
            Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees – Idea of West Bengal at Stake – Mohit Ray 19
            Trinamul Congress or Congress – compete with each other promising more Madrasas. Few
            years back when the case contesting the ban on Taslima Nasrin's book 'Dwikhondita' was
            being heard in Calcutta High Court, very young boys from different madrasas wearing
            Palestinian scarfs used to be brought in hundreds to shout insulting slogans against Taslima
            Nasrin, the rebel writer banished from Bangladesh.
            Rise in Muslim Population and Electoral change of West Bengal
            As discussed earlier, demographic danger is already a reality. Recent change of electoral
            constituencies in West Bengal show the impact. While the Hindu-dominated areas have lost
            the constituencies, seats have shot up in the Muslim-dominated areas. Kolkata, which earlier
            had 21 state legislative assembly seats now has only 11 seats. Again, Hindu-dominated
            Purulia and West Medinipur districts looses two constituencies each, one each in Bankura,
            Burdwan, Birbhum and Hooghly. Muslim-dominated areas e.g in Murshidabad, the number
            of seats increased by three and for both North Dinajpur and Nadia the increase was by two
            seats each. Malda, and South Dinajpur gained one each. Now see the demographic change at
            the 0-6 year level. The amazing 2001 census results show that while the Muslim population
            in state is 25.25%, their children (0-6 years) constitute 33.17%. Ambedkar's prophecy came
            to be true.
            Table 4
            Religious Proportion of Children (0-6 years) in 2001
            Region Population % Children % % Discrepancy
            West Bengal Hindu 72.47 64.61 -7.86
            Muslim 25.25 33.17 +7.92
            Darjiling Hindu 76.92 76.18 -0.74
            Muslim 5.31 8.26 +2.95
            Jalpaiguri Hindu 83.3 80.44 -2.86
            Muslim 10.85 13.8 +2.95
            Kochbihar Hindu 75.50 69.82 -5.68
            Muslim 24.24 30.0 +5.76
            Uttar & Dakshin Dinajpur Hindu 60.22 51.67 -8.55
            Muslim 38.47 47.0 +8.53
            Maldah Hindu 49.28 43 -6.28
            Muslim 49.72 56 +6.28
            Murshidabad Hindu 35.92 29.35 -6.57
            Muslim 63.67 70.27 +6.6
            Birbhum Hindu 64.69 58.42 -6.27
            Muslim 35.08 41.15 +6.07
            Bardhaman Hindu 78.89 75.0 -3.89
            Muslim 19.78 23.62 +3.84
            Nadia Hindu 73.75 66.71 -7.04
            Muslim 25.41 32.55 +7.14
            North 24 Pgs* Hindu 75.23 65.52 -9.71
            Muslim 24.22 34.0 +9.78
            South 24 Pgs* Hindu 65.86 55.41 -10.45
            Muslim 33.24 43.85 +10.61
            Hugli Hindu 83.63 78.94 -4.69
            Muslim 15.14 19.53 +4.39
            Bankura Hindu 84.35 81.8 -2.55
            Muslim 7.51 10.0 +2.49
            Puruliya* Hindu 83.42 81.62 -1.8
            Muslim 7.12 9.26 +2.14
            Medinipur Hindu 85.58 81.36 -4.22
            Muslim 11.33 15.36 +4.03
            Haora Hindu 74.98 64.81 -10.17
            Muslim 24.44 34.68 +10.24
            Kolkata Hindu 77.68 70.24 -7.44
            Muslim 20.27 27.81 +7.54
            Source: Census of India, 2001
            A Colluding State, Shariat courts and Assault on Democracy
            The rising numbers, violent methods and a colluding State has made the practice of
            democracy in state at stake. The share of Hindu population in border areas of West Bengal
            Presented at National Seminar on 'Migration and Its Impact on Indian State and Democracy' – 13 March 2009,
            Dept of Politics & Public Administration – University of Pune
            Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees – Idea of West Bengal at Stake – Mohit Ray 20
            are decreasing day by day. Bimal Pramanik has studied the issue of four border districts in
            details.52 His findings show the massive population growth, particualrly that of Muslim
            population in these districts. His extensive interviews also show that the Hindus are living in
            fear of life, property and dignity. There is a limeric commonly going around in these areas:
            Garu Rakhbi Campe, Taka Rakhbi Banke, Bou Rakhbi Kotahy?
            [You May Keep Your Cows In Camp (BSF camps), Your Money in Bank, But
            where can you hide your wife?]
            Listen to the admission of a district official,
            Village after village in Murshidabad, which were earlier Hindu dominated, are now
            Muslim dominated. Take Char Nirmal as an example. It has been completely taken
            over by Bangladeshis. Elsewhere in Bhagawangola block, Hindus have either sold
            off their property and left the villages for small towns and urban agglomerates or
            they have been pushed to the fringes of the villages. Barring the towns, where they
            have some presence, the Hindus are in a minority in practically all the villages of
            Murshidabad. The writ of the immigrants runs strong, especially in the border
            villages. The local administration is practically run by them. They are more vocal in
            their demands. On the other hand, the Hindus seem to have meekly given in. A
            section of them, though, is seething at the sudden assertiveness of the Muslim
            immigrants. 53
            The Shariat court is now common in these areas. The Islamic fervour is so strong that such a
            court in end July 2008 ordered and executed the beheading of a Hindu man. The wife of the
            man was a local Muslim girl who went to work in Mumbai and met the boy there. They had
            a son. While the couple came to the girl's village in Murshidabad, after knowing the religion
            of the person, the village court ordered to kill him.54 Muslim girl being lashed for unwed
            pregnancy (Murshidabad, April 2004) or Muslim bride being nailed into the knee for a
            claimed adulterous relationship in the absence of her husband, all are verdicts from the
            shariat courts (Murshidabad, October 2006). These are the tips of the iceberg, could filter
            through to the national dailies.
            In fact the show of Muslim muscle power as mentioned in the beginning, is becoming a
            common sight. There was a clash between Hindu and Muslims on 8 January 2009 at
            Medinipur town, during Muharram procession. Medinipur is a Hindu dominated area. Fear
            of Muslim violence was so serious that three weeks later, holding of Saraswati Puja in the
            town, a big festival for Hindus, was kept in hold, and was permitted just few days before the
            puja.55 The experience of Chandan Nandy during his study can throw more light on the
            borderlands:
            'In my travel in the West Bengal and Assam borderlands, the "considerable"
            mushrooming of mosques and Islamic seminaries, funded by money funneled from
            Saudi Arabia and other Gulf countries in West Asia, Iran, Kuwait, Pakistan and
            Bangladesh, was evident and backed up by government documentation which claim
            that these places of worship and learning have become hot-beds of fundamentalism
            and anti-India propaganda. When I met an 18 year-old maulana35 at Fakirerbazar in
            Assam's border district of Karimganj, who carried a book titled How Sweet and
            Beautiful it is to Embrace Death, it was evident how easy it is to label Muslims as
            fundamentalists ready to die in the cause of jihad. The easy availability of audio
            52 Bimal Pramanik, Endangered Demography – Nature and Impact of Demographic Changes in West Bengal
            1951-2001 , pp 65-108, Kolkata 2005.
            53 Chandan Nandy, Illegal Immigration From Bangladesh To India: The Emerging Conflicts, pp 169-170,
            Brandeis University, 2005
            54 The Telegraph - Sunday , August 3 , 2008
            55 Dainik Statesman, 25 January, 2009
            Presented at National Seminar on 'Migration and Its Impact on Indian State and Democracy' – 13 March 2009,
            Dept of Politics & Public Administration – University of Pune
            Illegal Migration and Undeclared Refugees – Idea of West Bengal at Stake – Mohit Ray 21
            cassette tapes of Bangladeshi Jamaat-e-Islami clerics like Delawar Hussein Saidi,
            preaching anti-Hindu and anti-India sermons, and taped eulogies of Osama bin
            Laden, only reinforce Hindu and official belief of growing Islamic fundamentalism in
            Bangladesh out to create a Brihot Bangladesh or a Greater Bangladesh carved out
            of the territory settled by its Muslim population. As one Indian writer explains:
            "Some of the Islamic militant groups of Bangladesh like the Harkat-ul-Jihad-e-
            Islami, Shahadat-al-Hikma, Jamait-ul-Mujahideen and the Islami Manch make no
            secret of their aim to establish a transnational Islamic state comprising Bangladesh,
            Muslim majority districts of West Bengal, Assam, Tripura and the Rohingya Hills of
            Myanmar." 56
            Expulsion of Taslima Nasrin probably signals the beginning of the last days of a democratic
            secular West Bengal. The Communist government imposed a ban on 'Dwikhondito' by
            Taslima Nasrin, Calcutta High Court rejected the appeasement of Islamic fundamentalists by
            lifting the ban. While the Calcutta High Court could thwart the Left Front governments'
            attempts to Muslim appeasement, the mighty force of fundamentalist violence took law and
            order in its hand to throw Taslima out of West Bengal. A day-long violence on 21
            November 2007, virtually supported by all the major 'secular' parties and 'secular'
            intelligentsia showed the shape of society to come.
            This 'neo nation' again flexed its muscle between 6-8 February 2009 at the heart of Kolkata.
            It went on rampage by attacking the office of the Statesman, one of the oldest newspapers in
            the subcontinent. The Statesman published an article by veteran journalist Johann Hari of
            The Independent, London, on 5th February, 2009, which criticized all religions. To protest,
            the Muslims started violence and continued for three days.57 No print or electronic media
            published any news about it. The Statesman editor was arrested and released later, but there
            were no sign of any human rights group or journalist's organization to protest. Of course no
            political party had the courage to say anything and as usual State colluded with the arsonists.
            This is probably the future of West Bengal. And those undeclared refugees, hounded out
            from home by a violent society and now hounded by a State, see it like this:
            'I had thought that my family and I had seen the last of Islamic fundamentalism in
            my village in Pirojpur in Bangladesh. But I can't say the same now that I am here.
            When we moved here, we had felt we had come to a secure place. Now I find the
            same Muslims, who raped our daughters and sisters, grabbed our land and
            homesteads, stole our cattle and agriculture produce, and persecuted us as my
            neighbour. We find the mosques blaring the same prayers that we had hated. We are
            told these mosques have now become the centres of fundamentalist activity in India.
            We are being overwhelmed again, by greater numbers of Muslims. Where will this
            all lead to? A time will come when we will no longer be as meek and timid as we
            were in Bangladesh.'58
            The author, on his campaign experience for last seven years, have heard similar views from
            so many undeclared refugees.
            ---------------ooooooooooo-------------------
            56 Chandan Nandy, Illegal Immigration From Bangladesh To India: The Emerging Conflicts, pp 173-174,
            Brandeis University, 2005
            58 Told by Babul Boral, at Dakshin Chatra, North 24 Parganas, West Bengal, on July 10,2005. to Chandan
            Nandy - Illegal Immigration From Bangladesh To India: The Emerging Conflicts, pp 175, Brandeis University,
            2005

            On the eviction of slums in Kolkata: A leaflet

            Click here to read leaflet [PDF, Bengali] »

            Feb 15 2010. From the Brihottoro Kolkata Khalpar Basti Uchhed Pratirodh Committee(Greater Kolkata Slum Eviction Resistance Committee), an organisation resisting the eviction of slums in Kolkata.

            Why this eviction? And why this declaration of war?

            Friend,

            Elaborate actions are afoot in various parts of Kolkata to evict slums, for the beautification of roads and canals, and for the "improvement" of the environment. The slum-dwellers lining Tipi, Manikhal, Chariyal and other canals, as well as Narkel Bagan and Hatgachhiya, face the prospect of being displaced from homes that are four decades old. The Kachharipara slum, Hosenpur Purbapara slum, and a number of other places face the same fate.

            To put a human face on this eviction, a portion of the displaced are being offered single rooms in the outskirts of the city. Drinking water, access to schools and hospitals, and the various other services a citizen needs are severely limited at these locations. The rooms remind you of gas chambers.

            The rest are told that they are illegal occupants. They have no rights.

            The reality is that "development" is another word for opening up the city for capital investment, ultimately to transform it in accordance to the needs of wealthy people. It is to make room for them that the government and administration have drawn up a program of eviction, with money from the Asian Development Bank. The Kolkata Environment Improvement Project (KEIP) and Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Rural Mission (JNNURM) are schemes that have been started with the aim of driving out poor working class people from the heart of Kolkata.

            Since the 1990's, Kolkata has been transforming, with big flyovers, wide streets, Multiplex shopping malls, apartment complexes, clubs, INOX, Swabhumi, Nolbon, Water Park, Nicco Park, and various other entertainment centers cropping up. There is no place there for the working class of the city - the hawker, rikshaw driver, small trader, small shopowner, slum-dweller, cleaner, and others.

            These people have been removed from their original places in the city and put into places like Nonadanga, Kasba, Kalagachhiya, ShampamirjaNagar. There they remain, bound by the State's legal bindings, much like the open jails of Lalgola in Murshidabad.

            They have lived in Kolkata for a long time. Their labour has been used by the wealthy, their votes have been obtained by political parties of all hues. And yet, in today's scheme of development, they have no place. They have been evicted from the dwellings, and have lost their livelihood and way of life.

            Let us protest these development policies of the Central and State governments, let us speak out against the demolition of slums in any part of the city. Let us stand beside fellow citizens as they fight for the right to have a home to live in.

            ************

            Invisible City: A documentary on the eviction of Ballygunj Rail Colony dwellers in Kolkata

            With English subtitles


            http://sanhati.com/literature/2141/

             

            Regular Columnists

            Digital Archives

            Lalgarh Movement

            Recent Journal Entries

            Ongoing Struggles in Bengal and India

            Nandigram

            Sections

            Recent Articles





            No comments:

            Post a Comment